I have the same dilemma, with a twist - I own Gronk, Cameron, and Finley, and can only start two of the three.
I was all set to play Cameron and Finley, but with today's news, now I'm wondering if I should sit one of them for Gronk (assuming he plays, of course).
Here's how I see it breaking down:
Gronk - He should be in good shape conditioning-wise from all the practice and he's the most dominant redzone option in the NFL when healthy (withTom Brady throwing the ball and without much competition in the receiving corps). But is he in real "game" shape? And will Belichick ease him back?
Cameron - He's another big redzone target with great hands, and was off to a monster start, but has cooled off as defenses have keyed on him more (plus, Weeden = not great). That said, as a Clevelander, I can tell you there was a lot in the local news about how the chemistry between Weeden/Cameron is still good and that Weeden will try to look for him more this week.
Finley - He's normally the ugly duckling of my three-headed TE beast, but this could be a huge week for him with Cobb and Jones out, and Jordy getting blanketed by Joe Haden (who is a legit shutdown corner).
Honestly, I'm not sure which of the three I should sit. What do you guys think? BTW, it's a PPR league...
Cheers!