rcswildcat Posted June 23, 2006 Share Posted June 23, 2006 i have been running my local going on its 8th year. for most of my guys this is their only league, and ff is just a way of trash talkin and getting together, so its not the most avid ff'ers. anyway, ive discussed going to ppr to catch up with the rest of the leagues since we are way behind the time. everyone thinks a change would be good and just told me to go for it. anyway, im in a few ppr leagues, but really dont know what the most common way of scoring ppr's are. we now have 1pt @ 25 passing 4pt per pass td 1pt @ 10 rec/rush 6 per rec/rush td pretty standard with some bonuses in there. trying to figure out the best way to implement ppr. i have a league that makes receptions 1 point, but has 1 pt @ 20 rec yards, which in turn equals the same amount of points in this system. i was thinking about making ppr .5 points keeping the rest the same. making them 1 point (the rest staying the same) would be another option. or maybe something totally different. im leaning towards the .5 pts per rec. any other ideas or suggestions??? any feedback is greatly appreciated Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
incognito Posted June 23, 2006 Share Posted June 23, 2006 I'm in a similar situation. I've been biased against ppr because of the effect on RBs. To me it's about relative importance, and football toughness. In the real world, I want the tough "north-south" RB who always gets positive yards and is capable of demoralizing the defense while burning clock to preserve a win. By the same token, the ppr bias for WR/TE is in favor of the tough "possession" receiver who can make the big first down in traffic. This I like. I'm currently considering adding 1/2 ppr for WR/TE only, and leaving the RBs as is. This may yield the best of both worlds. Has anyone tried a similar scoring system? My hesitancy is that RBs would lose value over WRs. Too bad we can't balance this with ppc for the RBs, as I may have to balance the effect by tweaking ppy. In the end, I'll probably not fix what ain't broke. ymmv Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Avernus Posted June 23, 2006 Share Posted June 23, 2006 I like PPR...it gives more options in bigger leagues... Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
johnsonk2 Posted June 23, 2006 Share Posted June 23, 2006 I am in 3 leagues and all have ppr scoring. league one : scores 3pts per reception league two : scores 2pts per reception league 3 : scores .5pts per reception I don't think it really matters what value you give the reception as long as it is across the board. I personally think the more points that is possible to be scored the more fun. In league 1 and 2 we also award points for rush attempts and completions as well. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
ebartender Posted June 23, 2006 Share Posted June 23, 2006 I am in 3 leagues and all have ppr scoring. league one : scores 3pts per reception league two : scores 2pts per reception league 3 : scores .5pts per reception I don't think it really matters what value you give the reception as long as it is across the board. I personally think the more points that is possible to be scored the more fun. In league 1 and 2 we also award points for rush attempts and completions as well. 3 PPR is a lot IMO. I have never been in a league with more then 1 PPR. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Bronco Billy Posted June 23, 2006 Share Posted June 23, 2006 (edited) Try a graduated ppr scoring system. Based upon your scoring for TD & yds, I'd recommend the following: RBs: 0.5 ppr TEs: 1.5 ppr All other players: 1.0 ppr It will balance the scoring nicely & move the top WRs & TEs into being 1st/early second round material, thus spreading the impact of RBs. Edited June 23, 2006 by Bronco Billy Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
darin3 Posted June 23, 2006 Share Posted June 23, 2006 Try a graduated ppr scoring system. Based upon your scoring for TD & yds, I'd recommend the following: RBs: 0.5 ppr TEs: 1.5 ppr All other players: 1.0 ppr It will balance the scoring nicely & move the top WRs & TEs into being 1st/early second round material, thus spreading the impact of RBs. This is a good approach. I've seen it applied and really does balance things out. Of course, just having 1 PPR isn't terrible either. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Bronco Billy Posted June 23, 2006 Share Posted June 23, 2006 Try a graduated ppr scoring system. Based upon your scoring for TD & yds, I'd recommend the following: RBs: 0.5 ppr TEs: 1.5 ppr All other players: 1.0 ppr It will balance the scoring nicely & move the top WRs & TEs into being 1st/early second round material, thus spreading the impact of RBs. Here's last year's top 50 FF player rankings based upon your current scoring: 1 Shaun Alexander rb 365 2 Larry Johnson rb 335.3 3 Tiki Barber rb 304.9 4 LaDainian Tomlinson rb 303.3 5 Brett Favre qb 272.24 6 Edgerrin James rb 268.2 7 Michael Vick qb 247.68 8 Clinton Portis rb 238.8 9 Steve Smith wr 236.8 10 Tom Brady qb 235.1 11 Eli Manning qb 232.72 12 Drew Bledsoe qb 229.76 13 Rudi Johnson rb 226.8 14 LaMont Jordan rb 225.1 15 Aaron Brooks qb 223.3 16 Drew Brees qb 213.7 17 Kerry Collins qb 212.16 18 Carson Palmer qb 211.76 19 Jake Delhomme qb 209.84 20 Trent Green qb 209.24 21 Larry Fitzgerald wr 205 22 Thomas Jones rb 202 23 Santana Moss wr 202 24 Mike Anderson rb 200.6 25 Chad Johnson wr 200.5 26 Steven Jackson rb 196.6 27 Peyton Manning qb 193.66 28 Matt Hasselbeck qb 192.74 29 Jake Plummer qb 190.06 30 Steve McNair qb 189.7 31 Joey Galloway wr 189.1 32 Warrick Dunn rb 187.8 33 Chris Chambers wr 187.5 34 Torry Holt wr 187.3 35 Anquan Boldin wr 186.3 36 Marvin Harrison wr 185.6 37 David Carr qb 179.72 38 Gus Frerotte qb 177.94 39 Mark Brunell qb 172.98 40 Willis McGahee rb 172.8 41 Willie Parker rb 172.5 42 Reuben Droughns rb 172.5 43 Antonio Gates te 170.1 44 Corey Dillon rb 169.8 45 Domanick Davis rb 167.3 46 Brian Westbrook rb 165 47 Hines Ward wr 164.5 48 Plaxico Burress wr 163.5 49 Cadillac Williams rb 162.1 50 Terry Glenn wr 161.2 And here is your top 50 2005 FF scoring with a .5/1.0/1.5 scoring system: 1 Shaun Alexander rb 379.5 2 Larry Johnson rb 359.8 3 LaDainian Tomlinson rb 341.3 4 Tiki Barber rb 339.9 5 Steve Smith wr 339.8 6 Larry Fitzgerald wr 308 7 Antonio Gates te 303.6 8 Chad Johnson wr 297.5 9 Edgerrin James rb 293.2 10 Torry Holt wr 289.3 11 Anquan Boldin wr 288.3 12 Santana Moss wr 286 13 LaMont Jordan rb 276.6 14 Brett Favre qb 272.24 15 Joey Galloway wr 272.1 16 Chris Chambers wr 269.5 17 Marvin Harrison wr 267.6 18 Clinton Portis rb 259.3 19 Michael Vick qb 247.68 20 Rudi Johnson rb 242.3 21 Todd Heap te 240 22 Plaxico Burress wr 239.5 23 Donald Driver wr 239.4 24 Tom Brady qb 235.1 25 Hines Ward wr 233.5 26 Eli Manning qb 232.72 27 Rod Smith wr 232.2 28 Drew Bledsoe qb 229.76 29 Jeremy Shockey te 228.6 30 T.J. Houshmandzadeh wr 227.8 31 Chris Cooley te 225.9 32 Steven Jackson rb 224.1 33 Thomas Jones rb 224 34 Aaron Brooks qb 223.3 35 Terry Glenn wr 223.2 36 Tony Gonzalez te 219.5 37 Reggie Wayne wr 218.5 38 Keenan McCardell wr 215.9 39 Alge Crumpler te 215.7 40 Drew Brees qb 213.7 41 Brian Westbrook rb 213 42 Eddie Kennison wr 212.7 43 Kerry Collins qb 212.16 44 Carson Palmer qb 211.76 45 Derrick Mason wr 211.4 46 Mike Anderson rb 211.1 47 Jason Witten te 210.7 48 Jake Delhomme qb 209.84 49 Trent Green qb 209.24 50 Randy Moss wr 208.5 Which one looks like it's condusive to having more balance in the league and mixing up your draft? Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
rcswildcat Posted June 24, 2006 Author Share Posted June 24, 2006 great help guys! i do like the idea of 1.5 for TE, .5 for Rb, and 1 for everyone else. ill have to throw that out there. thanks for the input Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
muck Posted June 26, 2006 Share Posted June 26, 2006 (edited) And here's a link to a league I commish with some interesting scoring rules you may like. The scoring is EXTRAORDINARLY even between QBs, RBs, WRs and even TEs. Of the top 25 players, we had 7 QBs, 8 RBs, 9 WRs and 1 TE. Similar results for the top 100 players, too. 6pts for ALL touchdowns -3pts for INTs 1pt for 20yds passing 1pt for 10yds rushing and receiving 0.2pts for each rushing attempt 0.2pts for each reception for RBs 1.5pts for each reception for WRs 2.0pts for each reception for TEs Edited June 26, 2006 by muck Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.