Defensive Backs

[puzzle head]

It is hard to find a forum which has a deep pool of IDP advice persons. Curious how you all think about this ranking:

 

Scoring:

 

Tackles: 1point

Assist Tackles: 1/2 point

Sacks: 2 points

Interceptions: 2 points

Forced Fumble: 2 points

Fumble Recovery: 1 point

DTD: 5 points

Safety: 2 points

 

1. Sean Jones (expecting him to take it up a level this season)

2. Gibril Wilson (I think he will flourish in this system as they use his talents at getting to the H-back but a gamble pick here)

3. Antoine Winfield (A little help this season which Winfield "should" benefit from and hopefully stay healthy)

4. Kerry Rhodes (I'm worried that his large pay day will damage his play a bit. He is good at interceptions: 9 the past 2 seasons)

5. Adrian Wilson (i drop him simply because foot injuries always concern me with Defensive Backs the following season)

6. Robert Sanders (i drop him here because I think the first part of the season Bobby will be rusty. I pray he is ready for TC)

7. Nate Clements (He had a great season last year towards the end. For some reason I believe he will struggle this year)

8. Charles Tillman (Good player but the Bears Offense will not allow the D-fence to stay off the field a lot)

9. Bernard Pollard (I see a very long season for the Chief's D-fence with a lot of tired players)

10. Roman Harper (I am torn between Harper at 10 and Troy Polumalu)

[Zooty]

Its not bad. I may move the CBs down a little. That scoring system really only gives points for tackles and turn-overs are hard to predict. Usually the high INT guys fall off the next year since QBs stop throwing at them.

 

I would move Pollard up and Rhodes down as well.

 

ETA- Points for passes defended? That would help CBs

Edited June 13, 2008 by Zooty