0
I will post our rules in a different topic.
The reason for this post is to show our scoring. Our goal is to get player value at the core positions as close as possible between offense and defense. We also increased QB a point in passing TD's to ensure player valuation remains high in this 14 team league.
What we did was score the defensive position uniquely at their position. As an example, and you will see we score more based on opportunity. DE/DT's as an example are awarded 3 points per tackle and 1.5 points per assist compared to LB's at 2 per tackle and 1 per assist.
The net result of these changes makes for an incredibly active league because of balanced scoring. It is more commonplace to trade a stud DE for a stud WR or a stud RB for a stud LB.
You will see when I post our rules the complexity; We use MFL but have a designed custom spreadsheet we use offline to ensure accurate management given cap hits, contract years and cash transaction.
I realize this type of league is not for the faint of heart but we have found it really marries the GM/owner experience.
I thought some of you may be interested if you are trying to design the best possible balance between offense and defensive players: As an example our league has 8 defensive players in the top 25 overall in scoring:
Hope it helps!
______________________________
Rules For DT, DE, LB, CB, S Event
Number of Passing TDs 5 points each
Number of Rushing TDs 6 points each
Number of Receiving TDs 6 points each
Fumble Recoveries 4 points each
Forced Fumbles 3 points each
Blocked Field Goals 4 points each
Blocked Punts 4 points each
Safeties 2 points each
Number of Defensive & Special Teams TDs 6 points each
Rules For DT, DE Event
Interceptions Caught 8 points each
Passes Defensed 2 points each
Defensive Tackles 3 points each
Defensive Assists 1.5 points each
Sacked a QB 5 points each
Rules For LB Event
Interceptions Caught 6 points each
Passes Defensed 2 points each
Defensive Tackles 2 points each
Defensive Assists 1 point each
Sacked a QB 5 points each
Rules For CB, S Event
Interceptions Caught 6 points each
Passes Defensed 1 point each
Defensive Tackles 2 points each
Defensive Assists 1 point each
Sacked a QB 7 points each
Scoring top 5 at each position thru 16 week regular season:
QB: (note we give 5 points passing TD and 6 points rushing)
Rank Overall
1. 1. Rodgers, Aaron GBP QB 448.42
2. 2. Brees, Drew NOS QB 411.58
3. 3. Newton, Cam CAR QB 394.82
4. 4. Brady, Tom NEP QB 389.78
5. 5. Stafford, Matthew QB 354.52
RB:
1. 6. Rice, Ray BAL RB 339.94
2. 7. McCoy, LeSean PHI RB 328.40
3. 11. Foster, Arian HOU RB 303.10
4. 19. MJD JAC RB 286.70
5. 28. Sproles, Darren NOS RB 259.40
WR:
1. 8. Welker, Wes NEP WR 324.80
2. 10. Johnson, Calvin DET WR 317.80
3. 25. White, Roddy ATL WR 266.70
4. 29. Cruz, Victor NYG WR 258.10
5. 32. Smith, Steve CAR WR 245.30
LB:
1. 16. Jackson, D'Qwell CLE LB 293.50
2. 17. Fletcher, L.WAS LB 291.00
3. 21. Laurinaitis, J. STL LB 275.00
4. 22. Johnson, Derrick KCC LB 272.00
5. 27. Anderson, J. CAR LB 265.50
DT/DE:
1. 9. Pierre-Paul, NYG DE 319.00
2. 18. Allen, Jared MIN DE 290.00
3. 23. Campbell, Calais ARI DE 271.50
4. 79. Avril, Cliff DET DE 210.50
5. 85. Babin, Jason PHI DE 208.00
CB/S:
1. 47. Harper, Roman NOS S 229.50
2. 49. Tillman, Charles CHI CB 229.00
3. 57. Woodson, C. GBP CB 223.00
4. 59. Byrd, Jairus BUF S 221.00
5. 64. Bethea, Antoine IND S 218.00
Edited by Ice1, 08 January 2012 - 04:25 PM.
