3 player keeper league. Need help choosing

[vmcarril]

I'm in a 3 player keeper league and I am stuck on who I should keep. I don't really have that one player that sticks out as a solid keeper. All of my potential keepers have question marks coming into season. Can you rank them in order of best keeper quality.

 

It's pretty much between these players. Rawls, Latavious Murray, Jordy Nelson, Alshon Jeffrey, Bortles, and Carr. I also have Kelce and I took a shot last year in keeping him but he underperformed. Don't think I'll do that again. Thanks

[Air It Out]

Kelce is always on the verge of a "breakout" year, so he may be worth keeping again. It also depends on PPR v. standard.

 

If Standard scoring, I'd go Rawls, Murray and Nelson. You'd have two decent starting RB (though Rawls may lose touches to Michael as the season progresses...I hope b/c I have Michael and need some RB help) and a WR in Nelson (I think he'll be just fine despite the injury - again, I have him, so I may be biased).

 

If PPR, Nelson, Kelce, and ... um ... Jeffrey? That's a tougher decision IMO. Maybe keep one of the RBs.

[vmcarril]

Yeah PPR. I'm a big Kelce fan but he'll never be "baby Gronk" with Alex Smith at qb. But I hear ya

[vmcarril]

So in a PPR if you had to chose one of those RB's who would you choose. Rawls or Murray. Thanks again

[Air It Out]

Gun to my head, I choose Murray, based on nothing more than gut feelings. I think Seattle is not all that great this year and the Raiders get even better.