This is a Non-PPR keeper league (Keep 4)
Start 1 QB, 2 RB, 2 WR & 1 TE.
My roster is:
QB - Newton, Ryan
RB - Best, F. Jones, Ridley, P. Thomas
WR - Dez, VJax, J. Jones, G. Little, L. Moore
TE - Dickson
The offer is I send Newton, Ridley & J. Jones for ADP, Freeman & B. Lloyd.
Obviously Newton > Freeman & ADP > Ridley. I think Jones > Lloyd as well, but that's not a big drop & I, most likely, would not keep Jones anyway. However, I would keep Newton.
I'd rather have McCoy from him over ADP or Kolb over Freeman, but this guy is not willing to make any changes to the offer. He came off as an ass IMO.
I think keeping Newton > getting ADP...