Just wondering if we were going to discuss any tweaks.
Top 10 -
1. Brady, Tom NEP QB 476.20
2. Romo, Tony DAL QB 386.20
3. Manning, Peyton IND QB 348.30
4. Roethlisberger, Ben PIT QB 338.72
5. Anderson, Derek CLE QB 321.00
6. Hasselbeck, Matt SEA QB 307.56
7. Brees, Drew NOS QB 307.52
8. Favre, Brett GBP QB 299.42
9. Tomlinson, Ladainian SDC RB 297.28
10. Palmer, Carson CIN QB
11. 11. Westbrook, Brian PHI RB 271.50 13.10 16.20 40.10 B 15.60 11.90 21.20 21.50 36.30 14.80 15.20 19.90 20.40 14.40 10.90 Bobbleheads 5
12. 12. Moss, Randy NEP WR 265.30 24.30 22.50 23.50 22.20 4.60 11.90 24.20 10.70 20.50 B 36.80 4.30 9.40 25.50 7.90 17.00 Soldiers of Fortune 10
13. 13. Warner, Kurt ARI QB 252.96 22.32 10.28 18.60 -0.16 20.28 B 4.88 26.16 20.24 28.36 17.76 26.48 25.32 32.44 Bobbleheads 8
14. 14. Cutler, Jay DEN QB 246.54 18.96 14.56 13.78 16.34 8.98 B 30.02 16.26 0.80 14.78 20.70 24.28 6.46 35.96 17.26 7.40 Hora Decubitis 6
15. 15. McNabb, Donovan PHI QB 239.76 13.26 11.10 38.94 4.92 B 16.42 16.84 20.62 13.66 36.74 2.16 14.26 19.62 31.22 Bobbleheads 5
16. 16. Kitna, Jon DET QB 238.00 29.26 17.00 26.94 20.78 2.54 B 6.78 10.62 22.58 19.76 18.08 14.86 15.40 9.92 19.08 4.40 Sharks 6
17. 17. Peterson, Adrian MIN RB 232.30 22.30 11.80 20.00 11.80 B 41.30 12.50 7.00 48.50 5.90 24.60 0.30 21.50 4.80 Harsh Hitters 5
18. 18. Addai, Joseph IND RB 232.10 20.30 14.70 21.10 20.60 B 10.70 28.90 28.60 7.20 16.60 11.80 6.70 26.10 9.70 9.10 Soldiers of Fortune 6
19. 19. Garrard, David JAC QB 229.56 16.56 18.88 16.36 B 15.62 23.44 2.88 19.96 18.54 22.78 22.00 25.68 26.86 Sharks 4
20. 20. Owens, Terrell DAL WR
Seems a little QB heavy to me. 4 points per TD would mellow this out.
Swiss Cheezhead
8/15/08 4:08pm
This is the only league I'm in that has 6-point TDs. I don't really mind either way, but it could affect keeper options, so I'd think it would have to be a unanimous vote to change.
Azazello1313
8/15/08 5:41pm
yeah, since it affects the assets people already have, I think it would have to be a unanimous vote for something like this.
but here's another way of looking at it. if you throw out brady's freakish year, the difference between the 2nd highest scoring QB and the 13th was 148 points. meanwhile, the difference between the #2 RB and the #25 RB is 143 points. the difference between the #2 WR and the #37 WR was 128 points. I don't think we have the ideal scoring system, by any means, but it is really hard to change that in a keeper league, and I don't think the numbers I just posted are THAT out of whack anyway.
QUOTE (Azazello1313 @ 8/15/08 6:41pm)

yeah, since it affects the assets people already have, I think it would have to be a unanimous vote for something like this.
I agree and can pretty much say that I would vote against changing the rules........that is unless someone wants to trade me the #1 RB for the #1 QB
QUOTE (justin @ 8/16/08 12:36am)

I agree and can pretty much say that I would vote against changing the rules........that is unless someone wants to trade me the #1 RB for the #1 QB

Well alrighty then... let's all draft QB's in round one!
Azazello1313
8/18/08 10:52am
I will point out that I won the league last year with the #11 and #19 QBs (#16 and #26 if you go by weekly scoring average). thews, you won total points with the #7 QB. justin won squat with brady.
just sayin...
QUOTE (Azazello1313 @ 8/18/08 11:52am)

I will point out that I won the league last year with the #11 and #19 QBs (#16 and #26 if you go by weekly scoring average). thews, you won total points with the #7 QB. justin won squat with brady.
just sayin...
squat =
Week 9
QUOTE (Azazello1313 @ 8/18/08 3:52pm)

I will point out that I won the league last year with the #11 and #19 QBs (#16 and #26 if you go by weekly scoring average). thews, you won total points with the #7 QB. justin won squat with brady.
just sayin...
We all play by the same rules, so it doesn't matter. Just think it would be a little better to drop passing TD's to 4. Maybe we can vote on this for next year?
Ursa Majoris
8/18/08 8:52pm
QUOTE (justin @ 8/15/08 6:36pm)

I agree and can pretty much say that I would vote against changing the rules........that is unless someone wants to trade me the #1 RB for the #1 QB

That'll be two of us. I'm in 9 leagues and they're all different. I don't want homogeneity, I want diversity, maaaaaaaaaan!