QUOTE (piratesownninjas @ 5/24/09 12:48pm)

Anderson has flaws, and Anderson has been beaten. 24-4 still means you lost four times. I wouldn't say Anderson Silva can do it all either, he's brilliant with Mauy Thai and great with BJJ, but he has holes. The only guys that don't are Fedor and Machida
What people fail to realize with Machida is that he's never lost a round on a score card from any single judge. Anderson is one of the greats, but has been submitted twice, lost on a decision once and lost by DQ as well. Anderson also hasn't looked good in a fight since July of last year. He's no longer fighting to win, but is now just trying to hold on for dear life.
Not to sound like an MMA elitist, but as someone who trains in BJJ, Muay Thai, and boxing and watches every MMA even that is on, I can honestly say that Machida is the smoothest fighter I've ever seen. His kicks were faster than Evans jabs, and the guy rarely gets hit. This is the one fighter that has the chance to be better than Fedor Emelianenko. His karate background is something that no one sees in MMA, at least not at his level. His BJJ is elite as he's a BJJ black belt and an all around freak. Tito Ortiz, who's one of the best ground and pounders ever couldn't take him to the ground, Evans jabs were slower than Machida's kicks... We don't need to be comparing Machida to Spider, because Spider would get throttled. Machida is Bruce Lee.
By the time all is said and done I believe Machida will be the best fighter MMA has ever seen. Doing it at LHW is far more impressive as he's already gone through some of the best in the game. Anderson's elite wins are over Rich Franklin and a 38 year old Dan Henderson. Cote is legit, but Anderson did almost nothing when Cote's ACL tore.
Any serious thought of Anderson moving up to LHW would be foolish, as Silva is a massive welterweight. He walks around at 210 so his advantage is skill+size. At light heavy he would be one of the smaller guys who would have to rely on skill alone, and if we learned anything from Penn/GSP, its that the bigger stronger guy will always win when they're on an equal playing field talent wise. If all goes to plan and Wand Silva beats Rich Franklin we'll be seeing Wand V Spider. It will be the first time that Silva has fought someone that big in his class and has the skill and mentality that Wand brings. That will be a true test for him. If he doesbeat Wand, he'll retire. He's said many times that he wants to retire when he's 35 years old, which is less than two fights away.
Agree 100%. I'm not going to claim to be an expert in MMA, or anything close. I do consider myself to be a a
FAIRLY knowledgeable fan of MMA, only because I try to soak up as much of it as I can get... watch EVERY televised fight/card (PPV or not, UFC, WEC, or whatever), and read as much as I can about the sport as well... online, magazines, you name it. I guess when I say that I'd love to see a Machida/Silva match-up, it's not so much because I think it would be a great fight as it is because I wish we could see Anderson challenged by somebody. I'll be clear about one thing... I agree that Machida is too big for Silva, and would overwhelm him. So, in that sense, it sounds like Anderson taking on Wanderlei might be a better match-up.
I mean no disrespect to Anderson when I say this, but his last few fights have been nowhere near impressive as the first couple that I saw when I started watching him. It's kind of like the equivalent of if the North Carolina basketball team were to have gone into the "four-corners" offense for the entire duration of the NCAA tournament with no shot clock... they would still probably have gotten the job done and won the whole thing, but it would not be nearly as exciting to watch as them scoring 90 points per game. Not that it's totally Anderson's fault, though, either. He's beaten everybody he could possibly beat in HIS weight class, and SAYS he'll fight anybody Dana White wants him to fight... It's just his game plan or approach to the last couple of fights that has been a disappointment. He's been fighting "not to lose", rather than going out with the expectation that he's going to seek and destroy, which is what he's used to do (even though he was always a little bit conservative in doing so, at least for first couple of minutes, when he's always been known to sort of feel out his opponent).
PON, what do you think the chances are that we will someday see a HW fight between Fedor and Lesnar?