I have C. Hope and I'm looking to trade one of these DB's.
Would be the better of the two that I should keep?

Elam's off to a very nice start, and admittedly I didn't think he'd be all that great this season. I think he'll be very consistent. Still, I think Atogwe is the overall better player - NFL-wise and fantasy-wise.

If I trade away Elam and Mario Manningham for Roddy White, am I giving up to much?

Granted with out your scoring system it gets a little tricky for advice, but I think that's a great trade. I don't think Manningham is going to keep putting up good numbers now that Nicks is healthy and I think White should start picking his game up now that they've had a week to start looking for ways to get the ball back into his hands.

Thanks, here's my scoring:

Defensive Players
Tackle Solo 1.5
Tackle Assist .5
Sack 2
Interception 3
Fumble Force 2
Fumble Recovery 2
Defensive Touchdown 6
Safety 4
Pass Defended 2
Block Kick 3

I'd say that's a pretty good trade if Roddy bounces back, not to mention he already had his bye week, so you have that out of the way this year.