QUOTE(Perchoutofwater @ 12/22/04 12:31pm)
Should the Confederate flag represent slavery. At the start of the Civil War, there were slave owners in both the Norht and the South. The Emancipation Proclomation was not given until over a year after the start of the Civil War. The cause of the war between the states was big government. The South believed in states rights, and the North wanted a more centralized form of government. The Civil War was about money, and natrual resources in the South. I know that now most so called history books wish to paint the Civil War as being about slavery, but it wasn't. Most people in the South did not own slaves, so they really didn't give a rats ass about the slavery issue, they were concerned with the federal government infringing on states rights. Why would the South risk war, over slavery, when a majority of the southerners did not own or depend on slavery? It was about fundamental differeces in the way they viewed the federal government should be involved. I am not defending slavery, I wish it had never happened, and think that it was a horrible practice, but the fact of the mater, is asside from the big plantations, slavery was not as rampant as the history books try to lead you to believe. The winner always gets to write history, and in this case the winner tried to hide the greed of the North under the cloak of helping slave, when at the onset of the war slavery was legal in many of the Northern States that were fighting the South.
[right][snapback]625823[/snapback][/right]
You are silly.
What northern states still permitted slavery in 1865? The states individually abolished slavery before it was abolished by the 13th Amendment, and the Emancipation Proclomation did not actually free any slaves, since it only applied to slaves in states that were rebelling.
Yeah - most Southerners did not own slaves - only the wealthy ones who just happened to be the ones who had all the power. The southern exonomy was dependent on slavery, the powers that be saw Lincoln as a threat to their economy, so they wanted to have their own country in which they could practice their slavery as they saw fit. Slavery was not the only issue, but it was the biggest one. Your romanticism about fending off big government is crap.