So I ended up accepting the trade. Afterward, the co-commish posted a comment about my "dumpster trade" and I was shocked to hear that most of the other mgrs agreed. That was when I went back and reviewed the pending trade and realized it included my giving up Hill as well!
When I first opened the trade on the yahoo app, it displayed Freeman for AD/Mariotta but apparently if I had scrolled down, Hill was below Freeman - which as this post confirms, I was unaware. On the yahoo app, it gives you the options to accept, deny, counter, etc, without having to scroll to the bottom.
The commish informed me this am that he spoke to a few of the mgrs and their belief was that the trade should be processed. When I explained the circumstances and sent a screenshot of what I saw on my end before accepting, everyone but the guy involved (who happens to be a co-commish) agreed that it should be vetoed. I made the realization and objected well before AD played last night, but the other team is holding their ground - he's claiming I got cold feet.
What are your thoughts? Should I be be held accountable for user error, or should I be given leniency for a mistake anyone could have made?