a deuce mccalister trade

[ndg5204 0]

i need some depth at rb i have deuce willis mcgahee and thomas jones i have been offered mike anderson steven jackson and muhsin muhammed for deuce mccalister and drew bennett so should i pull the trigger

[Bonedaddies 27]

I would not....too much risk of Inj to Anderson and Mushin, even though Mush played 16 games LY.

[Fenokee 0]

I'd pass on this one. Would Muhammad start on your team? Is Anderson a sure bet to stay healthy and be a productive fantasy back all season? If your answer to these questions are "no", or "I don't know", that means the trade boils down to Deuce for SJax.

 

Does that sound like a good trade to you?

[mhayhurst 0]

There is no way I would do that trade.

[ndg5204 0]

well my team consists of at qb drew brees and jp losman rb thomas jones willis mcgahee and deuce mccalister wr drew bennett joe horn eric moulds charles rogers and michael jenkins te heath miller and jeb putzier k stover dst panthers and chiefs. so my wr are a lil shaky so i was thinking about making him offer me mccardell muhammed anderson and sjax for bennett deuce and moulds

[Big Mac Bears 0]

No, don't do it. Deuce is going to be the man this year. You need to hold on to him and ride him all year just like the Saints will.

[jv378 0]

I wouldn't do it. IMO, McAlister and Bennett are a much better combo than than Mushin and Stephen Jackson. Making that deal doesn't provide you with much more depth or security at RB.

[Da Cuda 0]

i need some depth at rb i have deuce willis mcgahee and thomas jones i have been offered mike anderson steven jackson and muhsin muhammed for deuce mccalister and drew bennett so should i pull the trigger

 

997798[/snapback]

 

 

 

dont do it

[vikings711 0]

No. what would you be gaining? An injured Anderson and Muhammed (who has Orton throwing to him) for Deuce (a stud RB) and bennett (who is just as good right now if not better than Muhammed

[ts 81]

i need some depth at rb i have deuce willis mcgahee and thomas jones i have been offered mike anderson steven jackson and muhsin muhammed for deuce mccalister and drew bennett so should i pull the trigger

 

997798[/snapback]

 

 

 

 

 

The only way I'd consider that trade was if you could get the other guy to throw in a bag of commas, periods and other assorted punctuation.

 

Seriously, I think you're giving up too much for some questionable depth.