Opinions on this trade

[kpholmes]

My Roster-

QB - Hasslebeck, Collins

HB - Dillon, K. Jones, L Jordan, W Parker, F Taylor, T Jones

WR - R. Moss, H Ward, L Coles

TE - Heap

K - Janikowski

Def - Buffalo, Cinncy

 

His Roster-

QB - Payton, Vick

RB - Tiki Barber, Deuce Mccalister, Ronnie Brown

WR- R Wayne, Donald Driver, Santana Moss, K Mccardell

TE - Tony Gonzalez

K - Vanderjagt

Def - Pittsburgh

 

Trade-

I give K Jones, L Jordan and T Heap

He gives D Mccalister and Tony Gonzalez

 

Trade seems pretty fair to me, any opinions??

thanks,

Edited September 22, 2005 by kpholmes

[gilthorp]

Sounds like you made the trade already. Good luck with it.

[Montana is da Man]

You're giving up 2 starting RB's for 1 starting RB. I don't think I'd do it. Do you get a point per reception? Jordan will catch allot of passes this year.

[kpholmes]

No point per reception.

I like the boost at TE. And I'd much rather have Deuce on my bench then K Jones.

[NavinRJohnson]

Deuce and Gonzo, NICE. Unquestionable studs. I like the trade.

 

p.s. M-c-A-l-l-i-s-t-e-r

[kpholmes]

p.s.  M-c-A-l-l-i-s-t-e-r

1011327[/snapback]

 

heh thanks

[Perchoutofwater]

I don't like the trade. I'd rather have 2 starting RB's and a decent TE than one starting RB and a stud TE.

[kpholmes]

I don't like the trade.  I'd rather have 2 starting RB's and a decent TE than one starting RB and a stud TE.

1011334[/snapback]

 

However my RBs would look like this-

Dillon, McAllister, Parker, Taylor, T Jones, and i just snagged Marcell Shipp.

 

I think theres some decent depth there, and Deuce is much more reliable than K Jones, and the pass team Raiders,

[Ursa Majoris]

I'd do the trade. You already have enough depth at RB and Gonzo is a fine upgrade.

[kpholmes]

thanks for the advice everyone.