Better RB for WR deal

[actfootball]

Full PPR 

 

My RBs: Gurley, Aaron Jones, Nick Chubb, Sony Michel, Duke Johnson

My WRs: Keenan Allen, TY Hilton, Alshon Jeffery, John Brown

 

I want to bolster my WR corps before the trade deadline. Not many folks want to tango but one guy could go for either of the following deals:

Michel for Tyler Boyd

Chubb for Brandin Cooks

 

I am low on Michel and high on Chubb ROS so for that reason I like the Boyd trade. But I also get that Cooks is a stud and can do serious damage, especially with Kupp out

 

If you were me, which trade would you prefer?

Edited November 19, 2018 by actfootball

[actfootball]

bump.. hoping to throw something out today and maybe test the market on a few more deals before Wednesday

[shnugen27]

I think the Chubb for Cooks deal is fair, but I would try to do Michel + Jeffrey and see how high the WR ladder you could go before you deal Chubb.

 

I think the goal here should be to get someone in the Woods/Cooks/Diggs/Evans range.

 

Other alternative is to go Chubb + Jeffrey to see if you can break into the WR1s.

Edited November 19, 2018 by shnugen27

[actfootball]

I've been trying to work that angle (Michel + Jeffery/Hilton), but haven't had any takers. I think that people are forgetting how valuable Michel was in that stretch when he was healthy.

 

To be fair, I'm a bit nervous about Michel since Burkhead returns soon, but I still think that he'll be a high-end RB2 ROS.

[Montana is da Man]

If you are nervous about Michel, trade him for Boyd.  It's a fair deal. 

 

Cooks is obviously the better WR but you are giving up more to get him