• Content count

  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by chiefloganpsu

  1. My potential keepers in a standard performance scoring league (Start 1QB, 2 RB, 2WR, no flex):






    S. Smith


    I need to keep 2 (leaning toward Addai and S. Smith), but can keep a 3rd for an additional 50% of the league fee (so I'd be paying $300 instead of $200). League rule: The "keeper picks" are your first picks that you have in any round for as many players that you're keeping. I traded away Gore and my 4th round pick for a 1st round pick and Brees. So if I only keep 2, I will have "selected" them with my 2 first round picks and will be able to draft any non-kept player with the 2nd pick in the 2nd round (list could include TO, Holt, Westbrook or R. Brown, MJD or Rudi J., James, T. Jones, Benson, and whoever else I don't keep). I can also trade Brees, as my best offer at the moment is to get a 5th round pick (which would be the 3rd full round of un-kept to be drafted).


    Are any of these guys worth paying the extra $100 for?

    Should I stick with Addai and S. Smith as my 2 keepers?

    Who should I go after with my 2nd round pick if I don't pay to keep a 3rd player?

    I was going to ask if Brees is worth a 5th round pick, but the answer is quite obviously no. I'll see if I can get a couple other mid-round picks for late-round picks if he won't give up something earlier than a 5th.


    I feel I'm in pretty good shape regardless of what I do, but I wanted to get some other opinions.


  2. Eli vs. NO

    Kitna vs. Chicago

    V.Young @ Buffalo


    or I could pick up Cutler vs. Cincy.


    I think it will come down to Eli or Cutler, but I'm having difficulty trusting a rookie as my QB for my championship game.


    Should I just get over myself and grab Cutler to start or go with Eli?


    Your thoughts?

  3. Do I start:


    Kitna @ GB

    Eli vs. Philly

    VYoung vs. Jax


    Young got me to this point, but I also have Jax Def and I try to never start an opposing player against the defense that I'm starting...


    So, do I start:


    Jax @ Tenn


    Cincy @ Indy


    Are either of the QBs a better option than Young? If not, is Cincy worth the risk of a shootout at Indy?

  4. I'm planning on benching Kitna in my league, which is sad since I'll have to start Eli or Garrard. Detroit is on a short week, without KJones and there're rumors about Kitna being benched. And Miami's defense is solid. Only reason I'd consider starting him is that they're at home on Thanksgiving in front of a national audience, so they might get up to play.

  5. To at least narrow it down, I'd go with Indy, SD, Wash, Philly, STL.


    Indy plays Houston and Tenn twice each, including Houston in Week 2. SD looked too good on MNF. STL looks new and improved under Haslett. Philly and Wash are historically decent defenses to have.

  6. We get to keep one player and my best option is Steven Jackson. But if I choose not to keep him, I have the 3rd pick. I have a feeling that at least one of the following will not be kept or drafted #1 or #2:


    R. Brown

    C. Williams


    L. Jordan

    R. Bush


    What should I do? I can also announce not to keep SJax and then draft him if my top picks ahead of SJax are gone.