Mcnair or Warner

[isleseeya]

I have been riding warner who has been very productive last few weeks ...i think he does face a tougher matchup this week against the Redskins

 

meanwhile Mcnair , still banged up faces the Texans ( dead last against the pass ) at home , so i expect him to have very solid numbers

 

of these two WDIS and why ?

[yo mama]

I like McNair more this week, barring set backs. Though, Warner will get his yardage, regardless.

[isleseeya]

agreed ..have to check Mcnairs health along the way up until game time as well

[irish]

agreed like mcnair slightly more but injuries do scare me off.

[yo mama]

You just know that McNair is good for 2 or more TDs this week. So in leagues that award 6 points for passing TDs, he's solid. In leagues that awards passing TDs fewer points than other kinds of TDs, Warner starts to become a more intriguing play. However, both have had their share of problems with turnovers this year.

Edited December 8, 2005 by yo mama

[Bombs Away]

I don't see how you can bench Warner, he's been consistently throwing for 300+ yds, and 1 - 2 Td's per start. You never know what you're going to get with McNair. Don't forget that Warner lit up the tough Jax D for 315/2 Td's. Go with Warner.

[giantsfan]

I don't see how you can bench Warner, he's been consistently throwing for 300+ yds, and 1 - 2 Td's per start.  You never know what you're going to get with McNair.  Don't forget that Warner lit up the tough Jax D for 315/2 Td's.  Go with Warner.

 

1200323[/snapback]

 

 

 

I agree. With as hot as Warner has been I just don't know how you can bench him for McNair right now. He did pretty well at home against the # 1 pass D Jax, so why not the #11 pass D Wash.