Cotchery or Colston, Who has better upside in a keeper leauge

[Bork]

Who do you take?

 

Cotchery or Colston?

[tachamp]

Look Horn is done stick a fork in him, Bress likes the new guys Colston could be the sleeper of the year in the end. With L Coles the man in NYJ town all that is left over are scraps.

[DelmarJintsFan]

Hey, I basically have the same question - who's a better bet this year (I'm not in a keeper league). I'm totally torn on this. Every time I lean toward Cotchery, I see something about Colston. Here's what I'm considering:

 

For Cotchery:

--Pennington will throw more; Brees has good RBs to lean on

--Teams will key on Coles leaving Cotchery open

--Cotchery was targeted more than Colston in week 1

--Cotchery is a year 3 WR

--Colston is a 7th round rookie

 

For Colston:

--Could act as #1 WR since Horn's best days are done

--Might be Brees' safety valve, acting like Gates (this point alone is keeping him in contention)

--Great matchup against GB this week

 

Does this offer any insight? Post what you finally decide, I need help on this too!

Edited September 16, 2006 by DelmarJintsFan

[KUBJPO01]

In keeper league, I'd say Colston has more upside w/ HOrn being on his last leg. For this year however, I think Cotchery b/c Jets will most likely be playing catch-up a lot and Coles will see plenty of doubles. In all honesty, you can't make this determination on one game, both may not catch another ball for 2 weeks.

[Bork]

In keeper league, I'd say Colston has more upside w/ HOrn being on his last leg. For this year however, I think Cotchery b/c Jets will most likely be playing catch-up a lot and Coles will see plenty of doubles. In all honesty, you can't make this determination on one game, both may not catch another ball for 2 weeks.

 

 

 

I went with Colston, I felt that Cotchery has been trying to play for 3 years and just got his opportunity....I don't trust Pennington to stay healthy all season and am looking toward the future. I beleive Horn is in his last years with the Saints and Colston might (although a risk) really be the future #1 for them....we'll see, but I took Colston.