Gates & Steve Smith for Harrison & LJ Smith

[ROCKNE]

I know I asked this early last week. I almost pulled the trigger. Based on how well LJ Smith has done , would you make this trade? Here's my roster............

 

 

QB-Eli Manning

QB-Chad Pennington

 

RB-Ron Brown

RB-Chester Taylor

RB-Mike Bell

RB-Dominic Rhodes

RB-Brandon Jacobs

RB-Marion Barber

 

WR-Steve Smith

WR- T.J. Houshmandzah

WR-Reggie Brown

WR- Greg Jennings

WR- Jerricho Cotchery

WR-Keenan McCardell

 

TE-Antonio Gates

 

K-Adam Vinatieri

[tonorator]

given smith is a hugh question mark and i believe gates is a non-factor this year, you would be very fortunate to get harrision and l.j. the person trading would be going after name value alone, because both smith and gates look bound for mediocre seasons. it would have been nice if carolina would have been able to show us something without smith, but they have been dismal. he alone will not turn this around.

[ROCKNE]

Just saw on CBS that LJ Smith sprained his Shoulder. Still a good deal?

[Gros Membres!]

I'd do it. I think S. Smith may not see much action this year and Harrison is as reliable as they come. I also don't think there's much of a downgrade in terms of the Gates-LJ switcheroo.

[Capt. Stanky]

In a re-draft I;d do it, but in a keeper or dynasty 'd stay pat.

 

Fella's please lend a hand on my post "Getting Value for ABryant and ASmith?"