McAllister for Branch?

[dauby]

My running backs are Rudi Johnson, Edgerrine James, Deuce McAllister, and Maurice Hicks. My 2 starters are Rudi and Edge. I use Hicks and McAllister for buy weeks. I have been offered Deion Branch for McAllister. My WR's are Reggie Williams, Rod Smith, T.J. Houshmandzadeh, and Randy Moss. I think its a good trade because I'm weak in the WR area. Or should I keep McAllister and offer Edgerrin James? We start 2 RB & WR in our leagues standard scoring. Thanks

[Sharpie]

I would keep Edge over McAllister for sure. This trade leaves you only Hicks as a backup which is not very good. Is there anything available on the wire?

 

If you can at least handcuff your starters, you could make the move. Your WRs need help.

[chinatown dragons]

i wouldnt trade edge or deuce for Branch...being a NE fan, Branch just signed an OVER paid contract there.....there will be some grumblings with D jax over that......Deuce and NO are playing well..Id be surprised if Branch ends up with 7 tds this year....

[dauby]

i wouldnt trade edge or deuce for Branch...being a NE fan, Branch just signed an OVER paid contract there.....there will be some grumblings with D jax over that......Deuce and NO are playing well..Id be surprised if Branch ends up with 7 tds this year....

thanks for all your input. I declind his offer and offered him McAllister for his first round pick in next years draft. He is seriously thinking about it.