Make this trade? Pennington / Mason for Brees / Kennison

[nmack29]

My team is as follows

 

Pennington, Carr, Smith

Portis, Westbrook, Gore, Duckett

Chad Johnson, Walker, Mason, Michael Clayton

Crumpler, Franks

Akers, Wilkins

Carolina, Philadelphia

 

Roster spots are fixed - see sig for starters.

 

I was offered Brees & Kennison for Pennington & Mason.

 

Do I accept this trade? I think Brees will be better than Pennington (who was my injury replacement for Trent Green), but I think Kennison and Mason are a wash at best. I was pretty high on Mason coming into the year, but now an unsure.

 

He has Hasselbeck / Warner / Brees - Moss / Kennison / Burleson / Stallworth.

 

Am I in panic mode here?

Do I need to quit considering any trades or should I look to upgrade my QB with either Brees or Warner?

I am not sure why he is set on Mason being the WR he gets, but in my opinion he is expendable from my team. I am just a little hesitant to let Pennington go for Brees.

 

Grossman is available via the ww - as well as Colston and Cotchery. I am not too big on Kennison, so maybe I would pick up of of these 2 instead.

 

Any thoughts are appreciated. I just don't know if Brees for Pennington is a good deal, and throwing in Mason may not be the best idea either. I would rather drop Mi Clayton for one of these 2 WR.

 

Sorry for the long post - Thanks.

Edited September 20, 2006 by nmack29

[nmack29]

BUMP - any help is appreciated. This guy and I have been back and forth on who we want and I would like some opinions on whether to pull the trigger or not.

 

Thanks

[PCs]

not...it's a wash at best for you, likely a loss with Pennington tossing the ball all over the field with no running game.

 

I am confused by the teams - the one in your sig is not the one you list.

[nmack29]

I have 2 teams in 2 different leagues - both run by the same commisioner. I listed my team in question in the post, but the starting slots are in my sig - 1 QB 2 RB 2 WR 1 TE 1 Kicker 1 Def / ST.

 

Thanks - I just figured out why he is looking to make the deal - I think 2 of his receivers have a bye this week.

 

I was panicking a little whith the thought of Carr as my main backup, but hopefuly it will be for a bye week fill in. I waited to get a QB and then he got hurt - just my kind of luck.