Sign in to follow this  
Bonedaddies

QB's 5 thru 15

Recommended Posts

Here are my QB's after the top 4 are gone......please note scoring below......who would you move up/down more than a spot or two...anyone you see not on the list in this range that may be missing/sleeping out there??

 

5-Leinart

6-Bulger

7-Eli

8-Kitna

9-Hassel

10-A.Smith

11-McNabb

12-Campbell

13-Green

14-Young

 

I think I will shuffle this list a bit before the draft, and KNOW that I may have some of these guys out of wack, but rather than answer my own concerns......who goes up, who goes down, who goes off the list??

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I would say

Bulger

Hasselbeck

McNabb

Kitna

Leinart

Green

Campbell

Smith

Young imo....

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Here are my QB's after the top 4 are gone......please note scoring below......who would you move up/down more than a spot or two...anyone you see not on the list in this range that may be missing/sleeping out there??

 

5-Leinart

6-Bulger

7-Eli

8-Kitna

9-Hassel

10-A.Smith

11-McNabb

12-Campbell

13-Green

14-Young

 

I think I will shuffle this list a bit before the draft, and KNOW that I may have some of these guys out of wack, but rather than answer my own concerns......who goes up, who goes down, who goes off the list??

Leinart down towards the bottom of this list and McNabb up towards the top.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Bulger- top guy here, best WRs

McNabb- worth the risk

Hassel- steady

Kitna- Great weapons in DET, plus he said he'll have 50 TDs

 

These guys would force me to have a good 2nd QB as well

Leinart- Up and coming

Eli- Not Peyton

A.Smith- Make or break year

Young- rush yards will make up for his poor scoring as a passer

Campbell- very promising IMO

Green- I don't like the risk

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I would say

Bulger

McNabb well woth the risk if he can play like he did last year before going down

Kitna has to back up the 10 wins he predicts.

Hasselbeck solid when healthy

Eli solid numbers despite making some poor decisions in crunch time.

 

Leinart

Smith great weapons around him if all can stay healthy (Gore, Davis. and Djax.)

Green

Campbell

Young lost best WR and RB and is on the cover of Madden

Edited by Asskickas

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Bulger- top guy here, best WRs

McNabb- worth the risk

Hassel- steady

Kitna- Great weapons in DET, plus he said he'll have 50 TDs

 

These guys would force me to have a good 2nd QB as well

Leinart- Up and coming

Eli- Not Peyton

A.Smith- Make or break year

Young- rush yards will make up for his poor scoring as a passer

Campbell- very promising IMO

Green- I don't like the risk

 

 

Good stuff and I cannot argue your thoughts here, but here are my concerns;

 

Bulger- Holdout- if he signs, he should have a good year, how much will they run with SJ with another year under his belt?

McNabb- Worth the risk....reeeeeealy, if healthy he is, he just scares me!!

Hassel- LY I passed on LT and took LJ due to Rivers being a 1st year guy(oops) He should be higher than I have him now.

 

Leinart/Eli- These were the two guys I expected more replies that they were too high, the jury is still out IMO, both a risk, but no more risk than some of the QB's I have below them....thanks for the posts!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Rivers, Delhomme could be in there as well....one has Gates and Co. and the other Steve Smith.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Rivers, Delhomme could be in there as well....one has Gates and Co. and the other Steve Smith.

 

I have Delhomme at 16 and Rivers at 17, so they just missed my top 15. Jake's production has fallen for the last 2 years and Rivers has LT to run it in more times than they go to playaction pass to Gates. Though they are both very consistient QB's and you kinda know what you are getting week in and week out.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Eli is terrible down the stretch. At playoff time I agree with Zooty you need a good 2nd QB.

 

Vince Young lost all his weapons and I don't think his rushing yards will make up for that. Otherwise I agree with Zooty.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

No Roethlisberger? He'll outperfrom 2/3 of this list.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Eli is terrible down the stretch. At playoff time I agree with Zooty you need a good 2nd QB.

 

Vince Young lost all his weapons and I don't think his rushing yards will make up for that. Otherwise I agree with Zooty.

I don't know that I agree with what I said but I'll be slammed if I don't say it. Mike Vick Part Deux?

 

I would also put Rivers ( he finished about 8th in most of my leagues last year, the LT argument just didn't apply) and Roth. above half the guys on that list.

Edited by Zooty

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I don't know that I agree with what I said but I'll be slammed if I don't say it. Mike Vick Part Deux?

 

At least Vick has some first round pick WR's to throw to, and a good TE. He has no excuse to suck. Young may turn into a good passer but he's throwing to a bunch of practice squad cast-offs.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.