Is this a fair trade that I offered........

[jordanzs]

I'm the commisioner of our league, which means that I have final say if a trade is protested. And the guy that I offered the trade to is a first time player, so if I propose a trade that gets accepted, I wanna make sure that it's not too lopsided.

 

I have Brees & Cutler on my team, and would like to move 1 of them to upgrade my WR position. There's no good backup QBs in our league, so I'd like to get a decent QB out of the trade too.

 

So on the trade offered, I'd give him Cutler & Cotchery, and I'd receive Wayne and Eli Manning. Fair, or lopsided towards me?

 

I can also offer Cutler & Cotchery for Jennings & Eli Manning, since Jennings is valued less than Wayne.

 

Or I can also up my offer and propose Cutler & Evans for Wayne/Jennings & E. Manning.

 

Our league gives 1 point per 3 receptions, so it's sort of a ppr league, also bonus points for 100 yard & 200 yard receiving days.

 

For the QB scoring, in addition to bonuses for 300 yard & 400 yard passing games, I also threw in 1/8 point per completion, and -1/8 point per incompletion. Therefore, the QBs like Cutler & Brees who throw alot & complete a lot get these extra bonus points, so they're pretty valuable.

[breadtruck]

I think any of those would be fair trades, if he doesn't like one try the others. I don't think anyone else in the league could justify a protest.