Trade in Dynasty League

[KillerFalcons]

I got an offer for:

 

Cutler

Ocho

 

For

 

Campbell

Moore

2.2 iin rookie draft

 

I don't mind this trade I just don't kno If i should ask for Berrian instead of Ocho. Cause eh has Berrian. What do u guys think. Is Ocho better then Berrian and do u think this trade is good.

 

My Team: ( Just Qbs, Wrs, Rbs Shown)

 

Campbell, Jason WAS QB

Clemens, Kellen NYJ QB

Garcia, Jeff OAK QB

McNabb, Donovan PHI QB

Vick, Michael ATL QB (O)

Duckett, T.J. SEA RB

Johnson, Chris TEN RB

Jones, Julius SEA RB

Portis, Clinton WAS RB

Sproles, Darren SDC RB

Bowe, Dwayne KCC WR

Edwards, Braylon CLE WR

Jones, Brandon SFO WR

Moore, Lance NOS WR (P)

Moss, Santana WAS WR

Parrish, Roscoe BUF WR

Wade, Bobby MIN WR

Washington, Kelley BAL WR

White, Roddy ATL WR

 

 

His Team: ( Only Qbs, Wrs, Rbs Shown)

 

Cassel, Matt KCC QB

Cutler, Jay CHI QB

Quinn, Brady CLE QB

Rosenfels, Sage MIN QB

Forte, Matt CHI RB

Harrison, Jerome CLE RB

Jones, Greg JAC RB

Norwood, Jerious ATL RB

Tomlinson, LaDainian SDC RB

Arrington, Adrian NOS WR

Berrian, Bernard MIN WR

Davis, Rashied CHI WR

Floyd, Malcom SDC WR

Gaffney, Jabar DEN WR

Harrison, Marvin FA WR

Jackson, Darrell DEN WR

Moss, Randy NEP WR

Randle El, Antwaan WAS WR

Stuckey, Chansi NYJ WR

 

Our league is PPR, but idk if that means anything in this trade

Edited May 31, 2009 by KillerFalcons

[Big Country]

What are your lineup requirements?

 

I ask because you already have mcNabb at QB, with Campbell as a serviceable backup.

 

You already have Roddy White, Bowe, Santana and Braylon at WR

 

You would be strengthening your strengths at a minimum of cost, so from that perspective it is a good deal.

 

At RB you have Chris Johnson, Postis and the Seattle guys.... Not bad, but that is the area I would address if possible out of the positions listed. Any chance he would adjust the deal to make it an RB upgrade for you?

 

Now, I wouldn't just outright say no to his offer, as I do think it provides you with depth (I am torn on which WR to suggest, Ocho and his wackiness with no TJ there or Berrian with Tarvaris Jackson throwing to him, I would like more time to consider, but, given your solid WRs in place, go with Ocho.. more upside at this point IMO), but I would counter with something like saying, you know, this offer doesn't really address my primary need, but if we could push that to a later rookie pick (not sure how many rounds you go), or even modify the deal to be an RB upgrade (maybe he'll take the SEA RBs and something for LT or Forte.. can't hurt to try) you would be more inclined to say yes.