Need To Keep 3 of 4. Which 3?

[Johnny2247]

I am in a 10-team performance league with standard scoring, no PPR. We start 1QB, 2RB, 3WR, 1TE, 1K and 3 IDP. We draft 22 players. We are able to keep 3 players from the previous year that we did not draft in the first 5 five rounds. These are the four I am considering keeping and the round I would have to pick them:

 

Jones-Drew (11th)

Chris Johnson (7th)

D. McNabb (6th)

Felix Jones (22nd)

 

The first 2 are no-brainers as these are great value picks considering they are both first round projections in most mocks. I am trying to decide between McNabb and Jones. The only reason I am considering McNabb is that Brees, Brady, Rodgers, Rivers and Romo are being kept. This leaves Manning, Warner and a few others as the only top ten QB's remaining. I have the 5th pick and was considering picking a WR with my first pick. This would give me 3 of the top 10 players in this year's draft. Any thoughts on what I should do? Thanks.

[marcheese]

Without a doubt I'd go with Jones-Drew, Johnson, and Felix Jones. In a 10 team league, you'll be able to find equivalent talent at QB compared to McNabb.

[Bier Meister]

how is your defensive scoring and are your idp's worth keeping. also, if your qb scoring is 6 for passing td's, manning is still someone to consider with your 1st pick. do you have to keep 3? if not how could that improve your draft position (and options for qb, wr, and lb's)?

[Outlaws1]

I agree. You have to keep Jones-Drew, CJ and Felix Jones.