Big trade Offer! Should I trade Barkley?

[cloose 67]

.5 PPR

My team

Russ

WR: Robinson. Diggs, Landry, Chark, Beckham

RB: Chubb, Barkley, Javonte, Sony, Damien Harris, Darrell Williams

TE: Pitts

 

Guy offering me Terry McLauren, Chasr Edmonds, Tyler Boyd and Aiyuk for...

Barkley

Edmonds works be replacing Barkley all those WR any going to replace my guys?  We start two flexes and no kicker.

 

[stevegrab 1,430]

I think McLaurin and Boyd are better than Chark/Aiyuk.  OBJ is hard to peg now, but I think he'll be back in week 3 and similar value to Landry. I would not drop him but could drop those 2 and your lowest RB. 

 

I generally don't like trades where I'm getting more guys than I'm giving, or at most one more. This 4-1 means you need to drop 3 guys to make room. Maybe this owner (who will have 3 empty slots) is hoping you drop somebody he wants. But maybe its a smaller league (teams/rosters) and there are lots of similar guys on waivers. 

[cloose 67]

Thanks Steve.  Yeah don't need all that.  What are your thoughts on getting Edmonds ava getting rid of Barkley.  He has me very nervous.

[League_Champion 2,815]

No, and you'd also have to release half your team to make roster space 

[cloose 67]

@League_Championyou think Barkley is going to show out at some point?

I also have Russell Gage ava Fields.  I could drop Fields Gage. Darrell Williams to make room.

[League_Champion 2,815]

Just now, cloose said:

@League_Championyou think Barkley is going to show out at some point?

I also have Russell Gage ava Fields.  I could drop Fields Gage. Darrell Williams to make room.

 

As long as you have Barkley back in time for your playoff run you're fine. McLaurin is the only starter you're getting in return. No deal for me 

[zing 70]

What are your starting requirements? What does the rest of his team look like?

Edited September 16, 2021 by zing

[cloose 67]

@League_Championyou think Barkley is going to show out at some point?

I also have Russell Gage ava Fields.  I could drop Fields Gage. Darrell Williams to make room.

[cloose 67]

@zing

1QB

2WR

2RB

2Flex

TE

D

 

 

[League_Champion 2,815]

It's Saquon, a top ten pick in most leagues. He's definitely worth the risk. If/when he gets healthy you'll have a top 5 RB come playoff time. 

[cloose 67]

@zing

Hurts, Herbert. Mayfield

Adams, McLauren, Boyd, Aiyuk. Calloway, Kirk, Thomas

McCaffrey,Edmonds,

Waller. Goedert, Evertt

 

 

 

[zing 70]

I would stay put for now. See how Barkley, Edmonds, Ayuik perform the next 1-2 weeks. Is this a 10 or 12 team?

[squirrelmastr21 180]

It’s close. Can he improve on McLaurin or Edmonds rather than extra bench guys.

[Montana is da Man 3,621]

No dice.   Mclaurin is the only really relevant guy you're getting back