barlow for fitzgerald

[Redneck]

This is a 10 team keep league (6 keepers) with performance scoring. I am currently keeping D Mason, C Dillon, B Westbrook, D Mcnabb, K Corbet, and T Henry. I also own KBarlow but planned on dropping him as we can only have 4 RB's and I have the 2nd pick over all. I was offered a trade for Fitzgerald for Barlow (who I am not keeping). This means I would have to drop Corbert and am wondering if Fitz is an upgrade.

[yo mama]

This is a 10 team keep league (6 keepers) with performance scoring. I am currently keeping D Mason, C Dillon, B Westbrook, D Mcnabb, K Corbet, and T Henry. I also own KBarlow but planned on dropping him as we can only have 4 RB's and I have the 2nd pick over all. I was offered a trade for Fitzgerald for Barlow (who I am not keeping). This means I would have to drop Corbert and am wondering if Fitz is an upgrade.

 

901690[/snapback]

 

 

 

 

Hmmm. First, I like Barlow more than Henry. Second, I like Fitz more than Colbert.

[Clubfoothead]

I agree with yo.

[Haskel]

Ditto Yo.

[Adrenaline]

I would do the trade, it would be a nice upgrade at WR. IMO Barlow & Henry are both risky propositions.

Edited August 10, 2005 by Adrenaline

[Chaos]

Do the deal. Fitz has star potential if AZ can ever get somebody to throw him the ball. (I said that about Isaac Bruce once upon a time too).

Colbert will make a decent pick down the road, but Fitz at worst will equal whatever Colbert will do, especially in the current systems they are in.

[DocNiner52]

Barlow and Henry are risky but I give the edge to Barlow. He should be a good bet to be the starter in S.F. Henry does have the oft injured Brown to contend with. If Henry starts he'll put up better numbers than Barlow. Fitzgerald will put up better numbers than Colbert this year. I'd do the deal with deciding on which rb(Barlow,Henry) YOU think will have the better year.