Rate two team for playoffs!!

[Guest Bree22]

Scoring - Hitting: 1 pt for RBI; R; 1B - 2 pts for 2B; SB; 3 pts for 3B; 4 pts for HR and a sliding scale from 0-5 pts for avg. Pitching: 10pts for W and S; 1 pt for K and IP; 1-4 pts for ERA;-.5 for W and -4 for a loss. We start one at every pos plus DH for Hitters and start 4 SP and 2 RP. H-T-H weekly league. No limit on starts. Double starts are good no penalties.

 

Team A

Player TM Pos Eligible

Lee, Travis PHI 1B 1B,OF

Alomar, Roberto CLE 2B 2B

Rodriguez, Alex TEX SS SS

Pujols, Albert STL 3B OF,3B

Piazza, Mike NYM C C

Abreu, Bobby PHI OF OF

Berkman, Lance HOU OF OF

Bonds, Barry SF OF OF

Lawton, Matt NYM DH OF

Buehrle, Mark CHW SP SP

Lieber, Jon CHC SP SP

Abbott, Paul SEA SP SP

Lidle, Cory OAK SP SP

Sasaki, Kazuhir SEA RP RP

Rocker, John CLE RP RP

Lugo, Julio HOU SS 2B,SS

Chavez, Eric OAK 3B 3B Ortiz, Jose COL DH 2B

Wolf, Randy PHI SP SP

Oswalt, Roy HOU SP SP

Smith, Bud STL SP SP

Williams, Woody SD SP SP

Sabathia, C.C. CLE SP SP

Hampton, Mike COL SP SP

Fetters, Mike PIT RP RP

 

 

Team B

 

Player TM Pos Eligible

Helton, Todd COL 1B 1B

Soriano, Alfons NYY 2B 2B,3B

Vizquel, Omar CLE SS SS

Ramirez, Aramis PIT 3B 3B

Fick, Robert DET C C,1B

Dye, Jermaine OAK OF OF

Sosa, Sammy CHC OF OF

Dunn, Adam CIN OF OF

Burks, Ellis CLE DH OF

Millwood, Kevin ATL SP SP

Miller, Wade HOU SP SP

Schilling, Curt ARI SP SP

Maddux, Greg ATL SP SP

Williams, Mike HOU RP RP

Nen, Robb SF RP RP

Walker, Todd CIN 2B 2B

Womack, Tony ARI SS SS

Kendall, Jason PIT C C

Drew, J.D. STL OF OF

Clark, Tony DET DH 1B

Penny, Brad FLA SP SP

Wakefield, Tim BOS SP SP

Strickland, Sco MON SP RP

Saberhagen, Bre BOS SP SP

Manzanillo, Jos PIT RP RP

White, Rondell CHC OF OF

Sierra, Ruben TEX DH OF

Martinez, Pedro BOS SP SP

Pavano, Carl MON SP SP

 

Which Team do you think is better. Playoff are for three weeks single elimination.

[tornbicep]

Team A's hitting is excellent, but Team B's pitching offsets that.

 

Team A is depending on a collection of rookie pitchers to get the job done while Team B is trotting out Miller, Pedro, Schilling and Maddux.

 

Team A's hitters are all top of the line except 1st base and even that isn't shabby while team B has only got two real studs in Helton and Sosa.

 

All in all, I'd be more confident that the team B pitching staff will make the difference (assuming Pedro is back). It's a close call, but I'd go with B...

 

[ 08-03-2001: Message edited by: tornbicep ]

[Sushi]

I'd put my money on Team A. Team B's pitching is definitely better, but I don't think it will make up the difference put up by Team A's hitting.