Should I offer this trade? Would he even accept?

[cbraendle]

Should i offer:

Darren Sproles, Brandon Marshall, Marion Barber, and Eli Manning

for:

Calvin Johnson, Clinton Portis, and Jason Campbell?

 

My QB's, RB's, and WR's are:

QB: Philip Rivers

QB: Trent Edwards

QB: Eli Manning

RB: Brandon Jacobs

RB: Marion Barber

RB: Darren Sproles

RB: Knowshon Moreno

RB: Matt Forte

WR: Reggie Wayne

WR: Brandon Marshall

WR: Steve Smith (Giants)

WR: Donnie Avery

 

His:

QB: Jay Cutler

QB: Jason Campbell

RB: Ryan Grant

RB: Felix Jones

RB: Clinton Portis

WR: Calvin Johnson

WR: Santonio Holmes

WR: Percy Harvin

WR: Mario Maningham

 

I am pretty deep at RB, while he is somewhat thin. and opposite for WR. My league is ESPN standard, and starts 2 RB's, 2 WR's, and a RB/WR Flex.

Would he even go for this trade? am i giving up too much/little? Is it a good trade?

[jettxin]

Should i offer:

Darren Sproles, Brandon Marshall, Marion Barber, and Eli Manning

for:

Calvin Johnson, Clinton Portis, and Jason Campbell?

 

My QB's, RB's, and WR's are:

QB: Philip Rivers

QB: Trent Edwards

QB: Eli Manning

RB: Brandon Jacobs

RB: Marion Barber

RB: Darren Sproles

RB: Knowshon Moreno

RB: Matt Forte

WR: Reggie Wayne

WR: Brandon Marshall

WR: Steve Smith (Giants)

WR: Donnie Avery

 

His:

QB: Jay Cutler

QB: Jason Campbell

RB: Ryan Grant

RB: Felix Jones

RB: Clinton Portis

WR: Calvin Johnson

WR: Santonio Holmes

WR: Percy Harvin

WR: Mario Maningham

 

I am pretty deep at RB, while he is somewhat thin. and opposite for WR. My league is ESPN standard, and starts 2 RB's, 2 WR's, and a RB/WR Flex.

Would he even go for this trade? am i giving up too much/little? Is it a good trade?

 

I am not in favor over "blockbuster trades" trading just to trade after only 2 weeks is never a good thing.

I would not do that trade at all if I were you.