Why shouldn't I make this trade?

[countrychuck]

I've been offered the following trade by an owner who is thin at WR and I'm wondering if there is any reason to not accept. We start 3 WR. This is a NON PPR league, with yardage pts awarded to WR for every 15 yards. We do get 6 points for punt/kick return TD's. Thank you in advance to anyone who weighs in.

 

I trade: DeSean Jackson & Steve Smith (NYG)

 

I receive: Andre Johnson

 

Currently my WR are: Colston, Sims-Walker, Burleson, Harvin, and of course D Jackson & Smith (NYG)

 

If I make the trade I will have AJ & Colston as must starts, along with a best match-up rotation of Sims-Walker, Burleson or Harvin.

 

Here are the playoff schedules for the players involved:

 

AJ: Seattle, @ St. Louis, @ Miami

 

Smith: Philly, @ Washington, Carolina

Jackson: @ NYG, San Fran, Denver

 

+++NOTE+++ AJ plays 2 games in domes & 1 in Miami (good weather). Smith & Jackson play ALL of their games outdoors on the East Coast where bad weather would be almost certain.

 

Am I missing something, or is this a no-brainer for me to accept? Thanks again for the responses!!

[bbull82]

I like this trade a lot. However, currently DJAX is playing like a top10 receiver. If you would draft today you would pick him in top10. So I would try to get a throw in - maybe a TE or Defense replacement to go along with AJ.

 

Can you answer mine.

 

http://forums.thehuddle.com/index.php?showtopic=306498