Kolb on waivers

[P3R3]

I picked up Vick last week and that worked out great, thinking about picking up Kolb now and dropping vick now that he is cleared to play. I sent McNabb to waivers in order to pick up Vick, I could claim him back if I want. I am pretty bad at the QB position with Farve sucking this year.

 

Best QB's on FA:

Stafford

Hill

NcNabb

Kolb

[burton]

I'd suggest to keep Vick and try to drop someone else for Kolb. It's best to keep them both as who knows which will really start and when.

[delusions of grandeur]

Unless you really like to roll the dice or have alot of confidence that Kolb will come back and not struggle, then I think you almost have to go with the safer bet in McNabb right now...

[P3R3]

Is McNabb worth giving up my first waiver for? I mean I dropped him, if I knew then what i know now I would have dropped Jerome Harrison. If I claim McNabb off waivers I would have to waive Farve, or Vick (unless I wanted to stockpile QB's).

[Dowzer]

I'm in a similar position. I drafted Kolb and McNabb, picked up Vick of the WW after Kolb's injury.

 

I am starting McNabb with 100% confidence. Why? Because I am 100% confident that we will start and most likely stay in the entire game barring an injury. I have no such confidence that if Kolb starts that he will not put up a stinker in the 1st half and then Vick ends up starting the 2nd.