Which of these two trades

[dannygordo]

Earlier I posted for advice on a trade. I was being offered Peyton Manning, for Frank Gore and Matt Ryan. Since then, I've been offered a second trade by another team. I get Drew Brees, Michael Turner and Desean Jackson, in return I give Matt Ryan, Frank Gore, Roddy White. Which of these two trades is a better deal for me. I'm not eve sure I want to accept either of them. Personally I think I have enough at QB to go the distance, and I don't think I can afford to loser Roddy White. I am looking for any opinions, suggestions or advice. Currently I sit at 2-3, in sixth place, holding the last playoff spot. We are a ten team non ppr league. Standard Yahoo scoring, QBS are 25 yrds/ pt, 6 pt/ TD....RB and WR are 6 pt/ td, 1 pt/ 10yrds....Below is my Current Roster:

 

QB- Matt Ryan

RB- Adrian Peterson

RB- Frank Gore

WR- Roddy White

WR- Larry Fitzgerald

TE- Dallas Clark

Flex- Ahmad Bradshaw

 

BN- Big Ben

BN- Michael Crabtree

BN- Ryan Torrain

BN- Marshawn Lynch

BN- Mike Williams

BN- Brent Celek

[Tripleshot]

I'd sit tight and make neither trade. With Roethlisberger back, you don't have a big enough weakness to need Manning, especially at the cost of losing Gore. The second trade doesn't do much other than upgrade you at QB. See above for not needing a QB upgrade.

 

What I really would like to know is how you managed AP and Gore both in a 10 team league, unless it's a dynasty league.

[dannygordo]

I'd sit tight and make neither trade. With Roethlisberger back, you don't have a big enough weakness to need Manning, especially at the cost of losing Gore. The second trade doesn't do much other than upgrade you at QB. See above for not needing a QB upgrade.

 

What I really would like to know is how you managed AP and Gore both in a 10 team league, unless it's a dynasty league.

 

Thanks and I agree with you, we all know what Big Ben did last year.

 

I acquired Gore in a trade for Joe Addai, Malcom floyd and MSW. Guy was desperate for WR's and was loaded at RB