Trade Fitzgerald & Farve for Elli and Steve Smith?

[troy_21]

I am really trying to get this trade to where I would get Big ben, but is it really worth giving up with fitz for a QB upgrade (if you think it is an upgrade at least)

[SayItAintSoJoe]

Trade Farve and Fitz for Big ben and Smith? - yes

[troy_21]

That is what I am gunning for, but i am not positive he will bite.

[anubusknights]

I think your gonna need Farve to have a good game this week before you could get an upgrade out of him. His value just isn't good at all right now. With the QB situation in Arizona Fitz doesn't have a lot of value either. One of the 2 needs to have a great week before I would ever trade for them.

[troy_21]

anusbusknights, I believe you read the post wrong, I would be trading away favre and fitz for one of the options.

[anubusknights]

What I meant is that I don't see whoever you are trying to trade to giving up better players for people that just are not producing very much at all with any consistincy this year.

 

My post was from the point of view of who you would be trading to.

 

If you can get Big Ben and Smith for Farve and Fitz take it. Ben is gonna have a great year he is out to prove some things to people.

 

I got Farve and Fitz on my roster. I wish I could find someone to take em off my hands.

Edited October 19, 2010 by anubusknights

[troy_21]

What he really wants to give is elli and smith for fitz and farve. Is this fair?

[Tripleshot]

Nope, it's not fair. Personally I think you need another RB2 quality running back more than you need a QB upgrade. With the Vikings offense starting to click, and your other QBs, you can play the best matchup each weekend and be fine. I know Fitzgerald has sucked so far this year, but he's the guy Hall locks onto and Fitz has the skills to grab everything thrown his way when he's healthy. I still don't think the Cardinals go anywhere as a team, but Fitz could be primed for a big uptick in production and I'd hate to give up on him before we know how he shakes out.

[troy_21]

Alright, then what exactly do you presume I give up to get upgraded at HB 2? And another fyi, I am going with Kolb this week I believe, Farve is beat up and he needs to prove something before he deserves a start.

I have Best and he has been a very serviceable back. if I want to keep my roster in tact somewhat, I am not sure what I could give up without giving up to much to snag someone better. I am so high on best because it is a PPR league and Best gets his share of targets. Thoughts are appreciated