Advice: Holmes and Sproles for Mike Thomas

[EastCarolinaJet]

.5 PPR, and Thomas has quietly produced steadily all season long, and is honestly seems more like the #1 on the Jags than Sims-Walker. No TD's, and I keep expecting them to come they just haven't. Holmes may have immense talent, but Edwards is definitely Sanchez' go-to guy, perhaps even Keller ahead of him. Sproles just isn't worth a ton to be honest, though maybe with all the options going down he gets it going.

 

So who wins the rest of the way out?

[troy_21]

No. I have thomas as a bench player on my team, and he only fills in on bye weeks (he's done decent) but with QB uncertainty in J-ville as well as thomas not being an end-zone threat, i would pass and keep holmes.

 

 

http://forums.thehuddle.com/index.php?showtopic=337114

[EastCarolinaJet]

I'm actually the one with Thomas. It's a deeper league (14 teams), with a lot of flex positions and he's been very useful through injuries, exc. Holmes DEFINITELY has more talent, I just wonder if Holmes, being down the list, in a run-first system, with a team that won't always have to throw late in games like Jax, has enough potential. I'm leaning towards taking Holmes.

[Warped Allstar]

If you are the one with Thomas, yes, trade for Holmes. Once Sanchez realizes how much better he is, he will be throwing to him a lot more. I don't think I would ask for Sproles, he is 3rd on the depth chart now, and not really seeing a lot of future time. It would be a waist of a roster spot.

Edited October 20, 2010 by Warped Allstar