Trade Request. Need Advice

[rssfootball]

I have been offered the following trade in a keeper league.

 

I get: Ray Rice and Donovan McNabb

 

I trade: Drew Brees and Matt Forte

 

The rest of my team looks like this:

 

QB: Aaron Rodgers

RB:: Arian Foster

Steven Jackson

Jonathon Stewart

 

Should I make this trade?

 

Thanks in advance

[jrandall]

No that sounds like an awful trade.

[dazedandconfused]

Forte, even though will not be getting many goaline snaps due to Chester taylor but he still will touch the ball 18 to 20 times. Ray Rice will be sharing a lot of the load with Mcgahee. I think Brees is better then Mcnabb and I believe he has some more upside now have more of a connection with Colston.

[rssfootball]

Forte, even though will not be getting many goaline snaps due to Chester taylor but he still will touch the ball 18 to 20 times. Ray Rice will be sharing a lot of the load with Mcgahee. I think Brees is better then Mcnabb and I believe he has some more upside now have more of a connection with Colston.

 

 

I agree that Brees is loads better than mcnabb, but I would only start McNabb one time, when Aaron Rodgers is on a bye. I am looking to move Brees for a upgrade at other positions. I feel a starting line up of

 

Rodgers

SJax

Arian Foster

Ray Rice

 

would be very good with Ray Rice being my flex player. Maybe I am missing something. Also I got myself in a bind because Brees and Rodgers have the same bye week.

Edited October 28, 2010 by rssfootball