J.McCown over P.Manning?

[reddogs2020]

Superbowl week.

 

I'm inclined to start McCown since he has a better chance of throwing for 300+ (10 pt bonus in my league). That said, I think Peyton will throw 2-3 TDs before he sits. Hard to sit the guy who brought me this far, but the spectre of him getting pulled early is huge.

 

Normally, I wouldn't hesitate to start Hines. However, the Browns pass D is top 10 and has been extremely stingy the past few weeks. I don't expect Hines to do more than 75-80 yards (10 pt bonus in my league is at 100 yards) and maybe 1 TD. T.Heap probably won't get 100 yards in back to back weeks, but he is likely to get a TD or two (and he plays Sunday night!). I am leaning toward Stokley because he will play a full game (with no or very little Harrison to steal looks), the Colts will likely be playing catchup in the second half, and I read somewhere that he and Sorgi have some chemistry from playing together on the scout team.

 

Am I over-analyzing this? Should I just stick with Peyton and Hines and be done with it?

[wire-haired mangoblin]

i am starting mccown over peyton....please see mine.