WDIS - Cadillac or McCoy, Meachem or Gaffney?

[DAS]

I'm in a keeper league and Ray Rice is my #1 RB, so he is already starting, this is for the #2 position of 2 available.

 

Scoring is not PPR, 1 point per 10 yards rushing and receiving, 3 point bonus at 100 yards for each category. 6 for touchdown, obviously. We do count -1 for fumbles and -2 for fumbles recovered by defense and negative points for negative yardage (ouch!).

 

With that in mind, would you start Cadillac against Cleveland or McCoy against Green Bay?

 

Other available RBs in case I'm not picking the obvious two best are Leon Washington and Anthony Dixon, FWIW.

 

In my WR slots, same thing, 2 available, and I'm starting Randy Moss in slot #1.

 

For #2, I have available Wes Welker (really don't trust for Week 1 till I see if he's totally healthy), Julian Edelman, Jabar Gaffney and Robert Meachem.

 

With the negative yards and fumbles negs, I really have to consider defenses, which I freely admit is my weak spot, but I'm trying to pay attention and learn this year, so any help will be greatly appreciated! I'm definitely better at offense, for sure.

 

For informational purposes, my QB is Brady, TE is Clark, if that helps.

 

Thanks!

[homebrewer]

Gaffney at wr for sure vs weak Jax def.

 

McCoy over Caddy. McCoy probably breaks one/two big plays and that could be more than caddy's whole day.

[DAS]

Thanks so much!

 

So.... any point to trying to double my points by playing Brady, Moss and a third Pat by using Welker, Edelman (or Aaron Hernandez who is stashed on my taxi squad) when healthy? (It worked well in 2007....)

 

Or is that just counter productive and a time waster? I'm trying to learn to play smart this year and not intuitively if that makes sense.

 

Oh, and GB is my defense, LOL!

[NEPats]

I will definitely go with Gaffney - I think he's going to have a nice day and a great year.

 

I would also go with McCoy - TB is awful.

 

Thanks for looking at mine.