Trade Advice

[jtaylor1126]

I have been offered a trade of Ray Rice for Phillip Rivers and Matt Forte. Same guy has also offered up a different trade Ray Rice and Dez Bryant for Phillip Rivers, Matt Forte, and Roy Williams or Austin Collie.

 

Here is my team:

QB - K. Orton, K. Kolb

RB - R. Rice, P. Thomas, K. Moreno, J. Forsett, C. Taylor

WR - M. Floyd, R. Wayne, C. Johnson, H. Nicks, T. Houshmandzadeh, D. Bryant

TE - V. Davis

K - D. Akers

Defense - Cardinals

 

We start QB, 2 RB, 2 WR, 1 RB/WR, TE, K, DEF

 

His team is:

QB - P. Rivers, M. Ryan, C. Palmer

RB - D. Williams, R. Grant, M. Forte, C. Buckhalter

WR -B. Berrian, A. Collie, R. Williams, J. Maclin, D. Jackson, M. Sims-Walker

TE - K. Winslow

K - S. Gostkowski

Defense - Eagles

 

Would you take either or stay pat?

Edited September 11, 2010 by jtaylor1126

[delfamdelfam]

no, I think if you platoon Orton and Kolb you should be fine. It's not worth upgrading at quarterback if your depleting your runningbacks that much. With Chicago's bad offensive line and not knowing how Martz is going to use Forte and Taylor I wouldn't look to acquire him.

[MTSuper7]

Unless your league has a scoring system that makes QBs way way too valuable, I wouldn't do this. Rice is a stud, and the other poster is right that you'll be fine platooning Kolb and Orton. All adding Forte does for you is make your WDIS decisions harder.

[JetFanMike]

Not in a million years -- Rivers is a farily minor upgrade over the guys you have now, Rice to Forte (or Forsett, or whoever you would start) is a huge downgrade.