Mike Williams (SEA) or Negedu Naanee

[wang259]

Both Williams and Naanee are available on waivers. Who do you think will be a better pick and why?

[pdog]

Naanee!

He has a better QB and offense.

[JMC]

If you watched the KC/SD game last night, the Chiefs double and triple teamed Antonio Gates- they were determined not to let him beat them and he didnt do much after his first quarter TD. As a result, Rivers found Floyd, Naanee, and Buster Davis regularly and had decent success. On the other hand, with Seattle, there's Deion Branch, Deon Butler, John Carlson and a crazy RBBC there. I think Naanee is the choice and will have much better upside as opposed to Williams. I think Naanee could make the jump from #2 or 3 option to a solid every game receiver like Garcon and Collie did last year for Indy.

[Metalhead316]

Instead of making a new thread ill ask here...i have naanee already, but both Mike Williams are available...im torn on which to take. Seattles offense i feel can be more potent, but the Williams on the Bucs actually put up a TD...tough call, any other thoughts?

[lhamp]

Instead of making a new thread ill ask here...i have naanee already, but both Mike Williams are available...im torn on which to take. Seattles offense i feel can be more potent, but the Williams on the Bucs actually put up a TD...tough call, any other thoughts?

 

Between both Mike Williams I'd go with the TB one in a heartbeat. Yes, the Northern version has found a home in Seattle... and I'm seriously thinking of picking him up now... but the Southern version is a beast in the making. He's clearly their #1.... He just missed another td last week, a 70 or 80 yard bomb that Freeman (still recovering from thumb injury) overthrew him on. And he's only in week 2 of his career! He's going to get better week after week.

 

No comparison. IMHO.