Disposable Hero

I can protect one of the two. I'm already protecting ADP & Fitz. This is a 14 team salary cap/Keeper league. We can keep as many players as we can under a cap limit. We start 2 RB's and 3 WR's. The scoring for RB's is: 1 pt for 10yds rush, every 3 recpt., and 20 yds rec. Scoring for WR's is:1 pt for 10yds rec., every 3 recpt., and 20 yds rush. Bonus 1 point for 100/150/200yds rush/rec. for both positions. Who would you choose & why? Leave a link and I'll answer yours?

Which pairing would you rather have for this year? Burress/Maroney, Evans/Jacobs, Welker/Graham, or Roy Williams/D.Williams. Scoring is RB:6pts for Td's, 1pt for 10yds rush., 20yds rec. and 3 recpt. and bonus 1pt for 100/150/200yds rush. WR:6pts for Td's, 1pt for 10yds rec., 20yds rush. and 3 recpt. and bonus 1pt for 100/150/200yds rec. Let me know your thoughts. Thanks in advance.

I play in a 14 team keeper/salary cap league and we start 2 RB's, the scoring is 1pt for 10yds rush, 1 pt for 20yds rec., 1pt for 3 recpt, bonus 1point at 100,150,200yds. I currently have ADP & Earnest Graham at RB and Fitz/Welker/Romo as my keepers. Right now I have the 1.07 pick. I'm looking at possibly moving down to the 1.10 and L.White in a trade for the 1.07 or can possibly trade the 1.07 for 1.13 and move up in round to to 2.01 from 2.12. 26 RB's & 27 WR's(62 total players) were protected so were basically starting at pick 4.7. I'm pretty sure Parker/Edge/McFadden(hype) will be gone before 1.07/1.10/1.13 picks. These are the best RB's out there. Kevin Smith Matt Forte Chris Johnson Jonathan Stewart Fred Taylor Rudi Johnson DeAngelo Williams Ricky Williams Rashard Mendenhall Chester Taylor Should I swing for the fences with a guy like Chris Johnson/Jonathon Stewart/K.Smith or go with a more veteran back like F.Taylor or DeWill? I don't fee a need to grab a WR with my first pick as the RB talent pool will really drop off in Round 2. Any help would be appreciated. Thanks in advance.

I play in a 14 team keeper/salary cap league and we start 2 RB's, the scoring is 1pt for 10yds rush, 1 pt for 20yds rec., 1pt for 3 recpt, bonus 1point at 100,150,200yds. I currently have ADP and Earnest Graham and I have the 1.07 pick. 26 RB's were protected so I'm looking to pick a RB that will add some nice depth for me. There's not much to choose from but here are the best RB's left in no particular order Willie Parker Edgerrin James Rudi Johnson DeAngelo Williams Fred Taylor Chester Taylor Justin Fargas Kevin Smith Jonathan Stewart Matt Forte Darren McFadden Rashard Mendenhall Felix Jones I could take Chester with 1.07 to back up ADP but that may be a reach. My other protected players are Fitz/Welker/Romo. I could go WR at 1.07 but I think they'll be some decent WR's there with my 2nd round pick. Who would you rank as the Top 5 out of the above group? Thanks in advance.

I play in a 14 team keeper/salary cap league and we start 2 RB's & 3 WR's and the scoring is (RB - 1pt for 10yds rush, 1 pt for 20yds rec., 1pt for 3 recpt, bonus 1point at 100,150,200yds, WR- 1pt for 10yds rec., 1 pt for 20yds rush, 1pt for 3 recpt, bonus 1point at 100,150,200yds. My keepers for sure are(we protect by salary cap) ADP,Fitzgerald, and Welker. Which combo would keep along with these guys, anyone fits under the cap? 1) Rudi Johnson & Tony Scheffler 2) Earnest Graham, Santana Moss, Tony Scheffler 3) DeAngelo Williams & Santana Moss 4) Earnest Graham, DeAngelo Williams, Issac Bruce 5) Rudi Johnson & Earnest Graham Or I could trade Welker for Romo and then keep ADP/Fitz/Graham/Romo/Scheffler? QB's only get 3 pts for TD passes and 1 pt for every 25yds. I really like Romo, not sure if he'll be there when I pick 7th. I'm sure Brady/Manning/Romo will for sure be gone but Palmer or Brees might be there? I hope you can help???

Bump, Anymore opions on this? Leave a link and I'll answer yours!!!

Well I can see your case for Lynch being a PPR and a keeper league. Guys like Fitz or Wayne could be considered as well at this spot, being a keeper league I'd prefer them over Owens or Harrison. Tough call, but I think I'd go with one of the above WR being you can start 3 with the flex. I think Lynch is in for a tough year with the schedule he has. Fitz has a nice schedule during the playoff weeks.

I have the #3 pick in my draft this year and it's a 14 team salary cap/keeper league. We start 1QB,3WR,2RB,1TE,1K,1D. Right now I'm protecting Rudi/Fitz/D.Williams and debating on wether to keep Caddy or trade him before we have to select our keepers. I have nobody else to keep other than Evans but I can keep him with the other three, I'll go over the cap. BTW DeAngelo is free prrior to the draft. At the # 3 spot E.James/M.Lynch/A.Peterson(MIN)/A.Green should be available for RB's. My dilemma is do I keep Caddy and just draft the best WR, Boldin/Driver/Evans/R.Moss, 3 of the 4 will be available possibly all 4 or do I trade Caddy which I can get another 1st round pick (#12 or #10) plus a decent WR Branch + #12/R.Brown + #10(both owners want Caddy) and draft one of James/Lynch/Peterson/A.Green at the #3 spot and use the #10 or #12 pick for the best WR available. One of the above may slide there, probably R.Moss if any judging by the other owners needs. I don't pick again until 2.12 which I would then fill my QB spot. Any suggestions would be greatly appreciated. Thanks in advance.

The more the merrier!!!!!

I did not watch either of these players in college and I haven't followed Williams in his 2 years in the league so I know very little about either player. In terms of football talent, not situation/ supporting cast etc., who is the better player? In terms of Fantasy Football they appear to be equal but I feel usually the more talented RB will prevail if they play to their potential barring injuries. I know Adrain Peterson is more talented than both but is he worth the risk to take stash away this year as he'll most likely be in a RBBC situation. The reason I ask is I have Williams, could trade him, and look at Lynch or maybe Peterson, needing a them to produce RB2 #'s. I also have D.williams, talent wise how does he stack up? Give me your opinion solely based of football talent.

I play in a 14 team keeper/salary cap league. My keepers right now are Rudi/Cadlillac/D.Williams/Fitz. We start 1QB, 3WR's, 2RB's, 1TE, 1K, 1D. An owner in my leage really wants Cadillac bad???? He's offered a 1st(10th overall) & a 5th round pick for him and I draft 3rd overall as well. Cadillac was a disappointment last year and I have no real reason to keep him other than there will be very few RB's to choose from in the draft aside from the rookies and older on the decline RB's. Also he is an unquestionable starter, hard to find in a 14 team league. My idea was to counter with Caddy & Fitz for Parker and his 1st round pick 10th overall. With the 3rd pick overall I could most likely draft Boldin/Holt/Harrison, 2 of the 3 will be available. The owner with the #1 pick will probably take Manning. I could then take a quality QB at 10. Also I could then protect Rudi/Parker/D.Williams/Evans. Scoring for RB's is 1pt = 10 yards rush, 1pt = 3 recpt., 1pt = 20yds rec., 6pts = rush/rec td, 1 pt bonus at 100/150/200yds rush. Scoring for WR's is 1pt = 10 yds rec, 1pt = 3 recpt., 1pt = 20yds rush., 6pts = rush/rec td, 1 pt bonus at 100/150/200yds rec. Any suggestions would be appreciated. Thanks in advance.

I play in a 14 team keeper/salary cap league. My keepers are Rudi/Cadlillac/D.Williams/Fitz. We start 1QB, 3WR's, 2RB's, 1TE, 1K, 1D. An owner in my leage really wants Cadillac bad???? He's offered a 1st(10th overall) & a 5th round pick for him and I draft 3rd overall as well. Cadillac was a disappointment last year and I have no real reason to keep him other than there will be very few RB's to choose from in the draft aside from the rookies and older on the decline RB's. Also he is an unquestionable starter, hard to find in a 14 team league. The owner wanting Cadillac has Chester Taylor and I was thinking of acquiring him plus the 1st rounder for Cadlillac and work in some other draft picks to make it fair. With the 3rd pick overall I could most likely get Adrian Peterson(whom would be free to protect next year, we can protect 1 rookie free against the cap before the draft) and then take a quality QB or WR at 10. I know Taylor/Peterson will be RBBC but the thought of Peterson in 2008 intrigues me or should I just keep Caddy??? Any suggestions would be appreciated. Thanks in advance.

I agree with the others that Kitna is the way to go, he has a good matchup. I'd rather not take a chance against Chicago's D especially after losing last week. Thanks for answering mine.

All are pretty equal but I'd go with TJ. Please see my post. Thanks.

Reed