should i make this trade?

[gerry.harris]

i would be giving up E. Manning, Rudi Johnson, Randy Moss, and Matt Jones. I would be getting Tony Romo, Ronnie Brown, and Donold Driver. I really like Romo over Manning the rest of the way out as well as Driver over Moss, but my concern is giving up Rudi for R. Brown. Between these two backs, who do yall think will have the best second half of the season? Should i do the trade?

[Rockerbraves]

i would be giving up E. Manning, Rudi Johnson, Randy Moss, and Matt Jones. I would be getting Tony Romo, Ronnie Brown, and Donold Driver. I really like Romo over Manning the rest of the way out as well as Driver over Moss, but my concern is giving up Rudi for R. Brown. Between these two backs, who do yall think will have the best second half of the season? Should i do the trade?

 

 

Not crazy about 3 and 4 player trades but at first glance I like your side of the trade. Who cares about Matt Jones.

[JetFanMike]

I'd do it. You're giving up a little at QB, but Eli's been lousy lately. Driver is a huge upgrade over Moss (great matchups); and Ronnie has a much better schedule than Rudi. Ronnie's last 3 games are Bills-Jets-Colts!!

 

I happen to like Matt Jones, and think he'll do well, but I assume he's not starting for you anyway, while all the other guys involved are starters?

[craiginthecapital]

What's the rest of your team look like? Normal scoring seasonal league?

 

Assuming no keepers and that the rest of your team is solid (i.e., we're not talking about your #1 RB), then I think this is a good trade, not great. Romo should be better than Eli from here on out, but I think Rudi has the better upside at RB.