Advice on a Trade proposal

[Mooseknuckle]

Do you think this is a onesided trade offer?

 

I would be offering Santonio Holmes, James Jones and Hasselback and ask for Brees and Holt

 

The team I am offering has A. Johnson and needs a WR real bad!

 

His Lineup:

Brees

SA

Duece

Holt

AJ - OUT!

Devery Henderson

J. Witten

 

My Linup:

Hasselback

Addai

T. Jones or J. Lewis which I started this week Yippee!

Reggie Wayne

Santonio Holmes

Kevin Curtis

VD

 

He has no viable WRs on his bench either

Edited September 18, 2007 by Mooseknuckle

[Uncle Wiggy]

I wouldn't be able to hit the reject button fast enough if I were him.

 

Santonio Holmes and James Jones have upside, but jury is still out on both. So you basically want to trade 2 wildcards for a top 5 WR. And on top of that, you want him to throw in the better QB, regardless of what the early stats are. Try it, but I doubt he'll bite.

[MonkeyOne]

Do you think this is a onesided trade offer?

 

Yes, the other player shouldn't accept this.

[Mooseknuckle]

I am praying on his WR needs and the fact that Brees has been a huge disapointment for him thus far. Plus 3 players from his starting lineup are on NO he might want to trim that back a bit.

 

Thanks for your reponse though I may be way off base here.

[G.K.Trey]

I am praying on his WR needs and the fact that Brees has been a huge disapointment for him thus far. Plus 3 players from his starting lineup are on NO he might want to trim that back a bit.

 

Thanks for your reponse though I may be way off base here.

 

but by taking a WR from him you are making it worse, there is no way he will accept this.