McNabb vs NYG or Frerrote vs GB?

[Tega]

I'm up against someone with Berrian. This week should be a close one for me. I'm ahead by a few after tonight's game. I'm just afraid Berrian may catch one or two long TDs. I'm leaning towards Berrian.

 

I know a lot of websites have McNabb listed higher than Frerrote, but I feel the NY Giants def will give Phil a real tough time Sunday.

 

Performance scoring. McNabb or Frerotte?

 

Thanks in advance!

[jfrankparnell]

I'm up against someone with Berrian. This week should be a close one for me. I'm ahead by a few after tonight's game. I'm just afraid Berrian may catch one or two long TDs. I'm leaning towards Berrian.

 

I know a lot of websites have McNabb listed higher than Frerrote, but I feel the NY Giants def will give Phil a real tough time Sunday.

 

Performance scoring. McNabb or Frerotte?

 

Thanks in advance!

 

Big question Tega - how much does your league punish for QB turnovers?

GB might give up a TD pass to Frerotte - but they also might knock him around, cause some fumbles and get some INTs.

 

WashD brought this up (if I recall) - playing Frerotte on some level gives you a hedge against Berrian.

 

McNabb? Normally that's a no-brainer - you play your stud.

 

The Giants will pressure McNabb... and it's going to be tough. I might lean towards Frerotte too

[wildbluefan]

Don't overthink this.......MC Nabb, Frerotte has tough matchup as well, and always throws 2-3 picks !!!

[WashingtonD]

Green Bay historically plays very tough defense against Minny, and Berrian has had limited success against them...I'd roll with McNabb, I have a strong intuition that Westbrook gets loose in the passing game for some long gains benefiting McNabb's stats.

 

Good Luck and Check out my new blog post (address in siggy)

WashD