Sign in to follow this  
Steelhead

to Brees or not to Brees - keeper dilemma

Recommended Posts

Updated info based on changes in team’s keepers. 12 team 2 keeper league. Scoring at end of post. Up to 16 RBs, 9 WRs, and 2 QB are being kept (rookies can be kept as a 3rd keeper if they stay on roster the whole season).

 

I draft in the 12 spot. My keeper options are Brees, Gore, and Steve Smith.

 

EDIT: I also have Colston as an option. I can swap him with Smith or keep both smith and colston

 

My gut says keep Brees and Gore due to the number of RBs being kept. If I keep Smith then I’m drafting my RB1 in the group of Pierre Thomas, Grant, Thomas Jones, Addai. However due to the number of RBs already off the board there will be a long run on WRs in the first. If I keep Gore then my WR1 is going to be Ochocinco, Roy Williams, maybe TO if he slips (but doubt it). I did a couple mocks and here’s the results. With 2 keepers our first is really the 3rd round

 

Keeping Brees and Gore

3. Grant

4. Ochocinco (maybe TO)

5. Walter

6. Olsen

7. Breaston

 

Keeping Brees and Smith

3. Grant

4. Pierre Thomas

5. Walter

6. Olsen

7. Hester

 

Keeping Gore and Smith (or Colston)

3. Grant

4. Ochocinco (maybe TO)

5. Moore

6. McNabb

7. Shiancoe

 

 

Even though Brees is more valuable than McNabb I think keeping Gore and Smith gives me the best overall starters, though Brees is consistent enough to overcome either of the first 2 options. I am riding the fence on this and really trying to reason out not keeping Brees but I’m having a hard time not keeping the top QB. 1 pt per 5 completion is hard to pass up

Now that I have thrown Colston into the mix I think it could be Gore/Colston or Colston/Smith

 

Appreciate your thoughts on this. I have to decide by this Friday night.

 

Scoring rules

QB

1pt per 5 completion

4pt per TD

-2 per INT

1pt per 50yd passing

3pt bonus @300yds

2pt bonus @400yds

 

RB/WR/TE

1pt per 2 receptions

1pt per 20yd rushing

1pt per 20yd receiving

0.5pt/20yd IKR/IPR

2pt bonus @100 rushing

3pt bonus @150 rushing

2pt bonus @200 rushing

3pt bonus @150 receiving

2pt bonus @200 receiving

 

Start 1 QB,2 RB,3 WR,and 1 TE,K,DEF

Edited by Steelhead

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Keep Gore and Smith and target McNabb, Schaub, Cutler, Garrard...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Keeping Brees and Smith

3. Grant

4. Pierre Thomas

5. Walter

6. Olsen

7. Hester

 

I really like the above combo, but I agree that Smith (depending on health right now) and Gore are your keepers . .

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I just updated the first post with Colston. He's an option as well. If I were to keep him over Smith then I think it's Gore/Colston or Smith/Colston and drafting Grant and Thomas or Moreno/Wells then target McNabb in the 4th

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I went with Gore and Smith. I guess I have to let my mancrush on Brees go away

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I went with Gore and Smith. I guess I have to let my mancrush on Brees go away

 

you can always try to get him back in the draft

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

yeah I know...I would have to try to trade up to the 2nd or 4th spot to get him though. I have targeted Brees going to one of those teams due to their current keepers and what's available. no way he drops to me at 12. I am going to target McNabb, Warner, Rivers in the 3rd/4th rd unless there's still good value at RB/WR for my RB3 or WR3. Dropoff may not be that bad if I can get one of those. If I can't then I'm going late and taking a flier on Hasselbeck.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.