Interesting trade offer

[BadNews]

Ive just been offered the trade seen her:

 

I get - Kevin Smith and Brady Quinn

for - LT and Cadillac Williams

 

Here is my team:

 

( 1 QB, 2 RB's, 3 WR's, 1 TE, 1 DST, Standard Scoring, 10-Team league.)

 

QB's: McNabb, Cassel, Trent Edwards,

RB's: LT, Brandon Jacobs, Cadillac Williams, Beanie Wells, Ahmahd Bradshaw, Sproles, Ricky WIlliams

WR's: Fitzgerald, Steve Smith, Vincent Jackson, Devery Henderson, Nate Washington, Josh Morgan

TE's: Dallas Clark, Kevin Boss

DST: Packers, Cowboys

 

I like this trade, it seems to me LT is heading downwards (Ive drafted him both this year and last year) and K.Smith has alot of upside, and also I have alot of depth at RB.

Any opinions would be appreciated.

Edited September 16, 2009 by BadNews

[jordanzs]

I would counter it somehow. Get someone better than Brady Quinn. Personally, I'm higher on Kevin Smith than Tomlinson and consider trading straight up, but Cadillac for Quinn.....Caddy is hot right now, you can sell him for higher than Quinn.

[BadNews]

I think I could probably get a straight LT for K Smith deal. That seems more beneficial to me.

[IrishPride]

I would keep everyone you have but if you want to make an upgrade try to trade Caddy to someone for a WR? Someone who needs a running back and ask for the world and settle for your own Island...... Fish for the best value...Try the Derrick Ward owner? or someone who has terrible running backs.......

[cubdaddy]

LT for K Smith OR Caddy for K Smith...not both....unless you're are getting more than Quinn..

[wowzerz1111]

YUCK!