Would you make this tarde?

[mabucfan]

Need your advice on a potential deal - looking forward is always a dangerous game, but there is a team in my league desperate for a win this week while I am lucky enough to be a position where I can look forward a bit. Would you make the following deal?

 

Give: S. Smith (NYG), Roy Williams, and J. Jones

Get: Colston, Berrian, T. Jones

 

Smith has racked up a lot of points YTD, but his schedule down the line gets brutal - whereas Colston has started slow, and has a favorable schedule later in the year.

 

I think this deal makes a ton of sense for me, but I always like to hear from my fellow Huddlers.

 

Let me know you thoughts!

[Double D]

Not a bad trade. I would do it. Your team is pretty stacked so this just bulks up your bench mostly.

[mgdog]

i wouldn't.please reply to mine

[dfan88]

I like that deal. Colston should be a stud going forward. Hakeem Nicks is emerging as a big play threat for the G men which will likely take away some points and looks for Steve Smith. Thomas Jones is looking a step slower this year but is getting the goaline carries. Even as a Cowboys fan, I don't like Roy Williams at all. I think Romo starts to look for Austin and Witten more going forward. Berrian will likely produce the same as Williams though as Favre spreads the ball around. Harvin and Rice seem to be the preferred targets for Favre right now.

[nmack29]

I think the trade is fair. I think that Thomas Jones will eventually lose carries to Leon Washington, so this will favor you. To me the wildcard is Berrian. If he gets on the same page as Favre, look out. He is a great deep threat that can rack up a lot of points for you if he and Favre get hot.

 

I would do it.