Which One to Get, Collie, Naanee or Mark Clayton?

[dfine]

I need to shake up my bench. I have to start 4 WR's each week and must have 6 WR's on my roster all the time. WR & TE's are the same.

 

I have on my roster, DeSean Jackson, OchoCinco, Knox, Mike Williams(TB), Berrian and Cotchery

 

I am definitely dumping Cotchery and even thinking about dropping Berrian also. Scoring is 10% of yardage and 5 points per TD. NO PPR.

 

 

First rate from 1-3 who I should pick up.

Austin Collie(I do have Peyton Manning and Addai on my team already. Is this too many eggs in one basket, or he is too good not to take?)

L. Naanee(He is one of the starters, at least for now. I really don't see Jackson playing again for SD, unless a major injury happens. Naanee could do what Jackson did last year.)

Mark Clayton(He and Bradford did look on same page, but is this just a one week wonder? Is he better than Berrian?)

 

Also, Chris Cooley and Mike Thomas are also available.

 

Second should I drop both Cotchery and Berrian and try to get 2 of the 3 I listed above?

 

Thanks

[bbfootball]

Given the fact that you have Manning and Addai already I would stay away from Collie.

 

Naanee probably has the most upside with the list above.

 

I personally think that Clayton is one and done.

[dfine]

Anyone else. Should I drop both Cotchery and Berrian and put in for Collie first for Cotchery 1st, then drop Berrian for Naanee

 

Who are more people going to go after Collie or Naanee? If I don't get Collie and get Naanee, would you then drop Berrian for Mark Clayton. Do I hold on to Berrian?

[BearBroncos]

Collie is a stud, Nannee could be Rivers new man toy, especially on those deep balls....

[ajh2]

Pick up Collie, Naanee, and Clayton for Knox, Berrian, and Cotchery.