Need Some Trade Advice Please

[Chad]

My Roster is

Grossman, Losman

RBrown, LWashington, KFaulk, DRhodes, LWhite

Berrian, Boldin, Michael Clayton, Colston, Crayton

 

His is

Brady, McNair,

SAlexander, Fargas, Jerome Harrison, Kev Jones, D McAllister

Fitzgerald, Santonio Holmes, Houshmandzadeh, nate Washington, Reggie Williams, Reggie

 

I am getting

McAllister, Deuce NOS RB

Holmes, Santonio PIT WR

 

I am giving

Rhodes, Dominic IND RB

Colston, Marques NOS WR

 

Any thoughts or a good counter offer?

Standard scoring league, Non keeper

 

thanks

[soco]

so to make it short you get deuce and give up colston. I think that it is a good deal it's even it helps you at rb and you still have good wr to use but his team looks real good if you trade . I would try to counter by offering a D or a kicker or a qb ( McNair for losman )to help you . see if he bites you might get a better player at a diff pos to help your team... good luck

[downwithdisease]

This is really a push. In this situation i would rather have a rb or a wr. You can always find a wr to produce from waivers(i.e. crayton). It would leave you very weak at Wr though and Colston is your best player. If you start 3 wr though i wouldn't do it as rhodes would probably be serviceable enough as a number 2 back for the rest of the season(expect 5-8 points per week from him from here on out).

[Gros Membres!]

Nope. McCallister and Homes are not enough retur on Colston. Colston is a top 5 WR in my league. You should be able to get a Gore or Taylor for Colston. McCallister doesn't improve you enough to justify the trade.