Keep Bush or Peyton?

[NEPats]

Hey all -

 

I'm trying to decide whether to keep Manning again (have done so the past 3 years), or change up the scenery and keep Bush. Everyone gets one keeper to be selected in the first round.. I've never reached the finals of our league with Manning at the helm, and it's usually because all of the good RB's are gone after I select Manning as my keeper.. Since I finished 4th last year, I will have the 8th pick coming back in the 2nd round..

 

Quick scoring recap:

 

6 pts TD (rushing/passing/receiving)

1 pt 50 yards passing

1 pt 20 yards rushing

0.5 points per reception.

 

Thoughts on switching it up and keeping Bush?

[Bronco Billy]

At 0 ppr it would be a very close call, and I'd probably lean towards Bush because of RB value in the upper 10-15 RBs. With 0.5 ppr, it seems like Bush ought to be a slam dunk to be your keeper.

 

There's a reason you aren't winning even though you're keeping Manning.

 

Now, you want to try something really sneaky? Deal Bush & Manning together to someone in your league for a better RB than Bush when they don't realize they can't keep both guys...