Who would you rather have as your RB3?

[Shorttynaz]

I've been offered a trade in a PPR league. We start 3 RB's, and the Ryan Grant owner is looking to make a move to get another RB. I would be upgrading my WR's a little and my TE while sacraficing a little depth at RB. This is the deal he proposed..

 

He's giving me:

Steve Smith (CAR)

Vernon Davis

 

FOR

 

B Jackson/J Addai (one or the other)

Donald Driver

Brent Celek

 

My roster is as follows (we start 3 RB's and 3 WRs, 1 TE):

M Ryan, M Hasselbeck

F Gore, R Mendenhall, J Addai, B Jackson, D Brown, B Jacobs

R White, H Nicks, D Driver, D Mason, L Murphy

B Celek

D Akers

Vikings

 

Would you make the move? And if so, J ADDAI (splitting carries) or B JACKSON (not splitting, but in a pass heavy offense, and not sure about durability).

[lkirc]

Make the deal and give him B Jackson. Addai was probably a top ten back in your league last year. B Jaskson was standing on the sidelines yanking his crank.

[Shorttynaz]

bump.. Anyone else??

 

Make the deal or stand pat??

[draftmeawinner]

Make the deal and give him B Jackson. Addai was probably a top ten back in your league last year. B Jaskson was standing on the sidelines yanking his crank.

 

 

I agree. Make the deal & take Addai over Jax.