Please rate this trade offer

[NumerOneEaglesFan]

Vick for......Gaffney????

 

his team

 

QB - Favre & Frerotte

 

WR - Housh, Keyshawn, Mushin, Gaffney, S.Moss

 

RB - Ahman Green, Droughns, Barlow, C.Brown

 

TE - Wiggins

K - Tynes & Longwell

DEF - Miami & Baltimore

 

NOW....the good thing is that he is interested in Vick.....so I am trying to think of a good counter offer......in lyes where I need the HELP.

 

I was thinkin' S.Moss for Vick and........Ferguson????

 

or just Vick for S.Moss ???

 

ty in advance for your input.

[bent1969]

with s.moss's breakout game monday, he won't bait. k.johnson would be the only one he would give up.

[ts]

Won't hurt to ask:

 

Try Vick (& Fergie if need be) for TJ or Mushin ... all he can do is say "no", why not find out how much interest he really has in Vick after all?

Edited September 22, 2005 by ts

[Roo]

I'd hold on to Vick.

 

If you only can start 2 WRs, then you really have no reason to trade. If you start 3, then maybe.

 

Vick is the type of player than can get hot. And considering your other QBs are not exactly studs, you might at some point find he has the best matchup.

 

I'd be packaging an RB (nice depth) for a top QB.

Edited September 22, 2005 by Roo

[NumerOneEaglesFan]

I'd hold on to Vick.

 

If you only can start 2 WRs, then you really have no reason to trade.  If you start 3, then maybe. 

 

Vick is the type of player than can get hot.  And considering your other QBs are not exactly studs, you might at some point find he has the best matchup.

 

I'd be packaging an RB (nice depth) for a top QB.

 

1012049[/snapback]

 

 

 

 

ok.....we do start 3 WR's

 

Which RB would u deal???

 

I am thinkin of trying to get McNabb for Vick n Parker or Caddy.....

Edited September 22, 2005 by NumerOneEaglesFan